The Debate Between Ulama's Of Sunnah
And Shi'ah: Religion Based On The Motives Of Revenge
09 August 2012
By Ikhwan Al-Mujahidun
A King of Iran had summoned all the Ulama's of Sunnah
and Shi'ah, aiming to find out the difference between
All the Ulama's of Shi'ah presented themselves, but
one Ulama' of Sunnah arrived a bit late compared to
other Ulama's of Sunnah. That Ulama' of Sunnah was
walking while clutching his shoes to his body with his
arm... The Ulama's of Shi'ah looked in astonishment
while saying, "Why are you clutching your shoes like
That Ulama' of Sunnah answered, "I have heard that
during the time of Rasulullah (SAW), the Shi'ahs like
to steal shoes!"
The Ulama's of Shi'ah answered, "There was no Shi'ah
during the time of Rasulullah (SAW)."
The Ulama' of Sunnah said, "So, our debate has ended.
The bottom line is, where does your religion come
from?" Sheikh Ahmed Deedat
Ustadz Abu Rusydan: Shi'ah's
Emergence Based On The Motives Of Revenge Of The Majus
Meanwhile, in Solo, Indonesia Ustadz Abu Rusydan, in
the solidarity and fund-raising event for Muslims in
Syria entitled "Save Syria – Let's Pray For Them" at
Masjid Baitul Makmur, Solo, Central Java, Sunday
morning (15/7/2012) explained that Shi'ah is a sect
outside of Islam. Thus, it is very strange if there
are some Muslims who say that Shi'ah is a mazhab from
among the mazhabs in Islam.
"There are those who argue that the conflict in Syria
is a sectarian conflict, between the Shi'ah and the
Sunni sect. Once again I say ayyuhal ikhwah, in the
book "Ja'a Daurul Majus" it is mentioned that Shi'ah
is not a sect of Islam, Shi'ah is not a mazhab in
Islam," said the Ustadz.
According to him, from the early history of the
emergence of Shi'ah alone, it can already be known
that the origination of Shi'ah is from the religion of
Majus with the motif of revenge. So how can the
Majusis be included into one of the Islamic groups.
"But the root of the emergence of Shi'ah was from
Majus. That today the Majusis have already held very
remarkable roles by implanting their talons and fangs
in the Islamic world. And the inception of Shi'ah came
from the vengeance of the Majusi Persians against
Islam, and then they collaborated with the Jews and
Christians," said this Ustadz who had attended the
military training in Afghanistan.
Next, the former official of the Jamaah Islamiah also
explained that in truth, between Iran (Shi'ah),
America (Christian) and Israel (Jewish), they are a
one body or conspiring, this could be seen when the
Taliban's rule in Afghanistan fell.
"One of the conspiracies of Iran, America and Northern
Alliance was seen when the Taliban in Afghanistan
fell. In electing a leader, whether it would be
Amanullah Khan or the others, as they didn't let
anyone from the Ahlus Sunnah become a leader, in the
end they elected Hamid Karzai. And Hamid Karzai is a
follower of Baha'i, one of the sect of Shi'ah, and I
got to know that apparently Mahmud Abbas is the
follower of Shi'ah Al-Babiyah. So once again, Shi'ah,
to this day, with all sects, whatever the names, is
bathil, which later was paved by the Western
invaders," he disclosed.