Home | Site Explorer | Media Window | Writers | Fatwa Request | Bizaar | Donations | About Us | Our Sheikh | Contact Us

 
 

Dave Lindorff's Articles**

 AddThis Feed Button

Idiots And Bailouts: Reason Before Eyes - Bloated Megacorporation Run By Idiots

 
Posted By Dave Lindorff

November 24, 2008

Its a safe bet that within the next several months, Congress will vote to bail out General Motors. It will be a colossal boondoggle involving, probably, upwards of $50 billion when its through, and it will fail in the end.

The reason is before our eyes. This bloated megacorporation is being run by idiots.

For years, as it became evident to everyone that oil prices were going to soar because demand has been exceeding both production and supply and will continue to do so, it has been obvious that to succeed, a car company had to offer well-made cars that could demonstrate high gas mileage. GM, perhaps more than any other company, ignored that reality and has been paying the price, watching its share of the car market wither.

Now the company, worth about what Starbucks used to be worth, its stock now down to where it was in the depths of the Great Depression, has bet the farm on a new car, the Volt, which it promises will, two years from now, be able to go all of 40 miles purely on electric power. It will have a motor too, and not a small one, but rather one the size of what you get in a typical conventional Honda Civic1.4 ltr. That motor wouldnt drive the car; rather it would keep charging the Volts huge lithium-ion battery so the car could keep going for a few hundred miles.

Wow.

The management wizards at GM obviously dont do much driving. If they did, and found themselves in typical commuter traffic, theyd see that maybe 90% of the cars, or more, have only one person in them. Occasionally, theyd see a passenger. On a typical 45-minute trip from the burbs into Philadelphia at rush hour, I can count the number of cars I see with three or more people in them on my fingers.

So why is GM making the Volt as a full-sized four or five-passenger car? Thats not where the market for an electric car is. What is needed is a two-seater little car.

Because GM is trying to make an electric family car, theyve made something so big that, if they are lucky, theyll be able to get it to 40 miles on electric drive only, but at a cost in excess of $40,000 and perhaps much higher, which will put it out of almost everyones reach. The car is destined to be a bust.

And yet, because President-elect Obama will want to win Michigan next election, and because Congressional Democrats dont want to be seen as ignoring the fate of GMs workers, GM will be bailed out and the Volt will be funded right through to its introduction and subsequent disaster in the market.

Im not opposed to the idea of government support of industry, but that support has to involve government input or even control over decision-making.

Maybe GM wouldnt make much profit on a little electric commuter car, but a little two-seater electric commuter car would have a huge impact on reducing the output of hydrocarbons into the atmosphere, particularly if efforts were made to increase solar and wind-generated electricity. A small electric commuter car would also massively reduce the amount of oil the US imports, making a major contribution to reducing the nations trade deficit. Those are results that justify a bailout.

Making an overpriced electric family car is not.

At this point, since the Democrats in Congress and the White House are congenitally incapable of imagining a state-owned or partially state-owned enterprise, it would be better to just let GM go under, and maybe Ford too, if it comes to that (another stupid company). The pieces could be sold off, and allowed to sink and swim on their own. Maybe one of those smaller, more entrepreneurial fragments would see the wisdom of developing what the public really needs.

The truth is that the entrepreneurs over at Tesla, a start-up in California, have already made that cara high-performance two-seater commuter car that can go 200 miles on a charge and that doesnt need an auxiliary engine. Their problem is that small size and too little capital have forced them to pimp it up into a high-priced luxury show-off item for rich people costing $100,000. If they were to team up with a GM spin-offsay Saturnthey could make a stripped-down version of that baby and crank out 100,000 of them to start at a price ordinary people could afford.

Meanwhile, regarding those poor autoworkers, they have a legitimate complaint. While Republicans like to blame the auto industrys problems on them, saying they have demanded too much pay, and too much in healthcare benefits, its not their fault that GM and Ford executives have been stupid and greedy and short-sighted (besides, the high wages and benefits that the United Auto Workers won over decades of bitter struggle helped to set standards that raised the wages of all workers across the nation). But lets do the math. There are about 125,000 unionized hourly workers at the two companies. For a lousy $8.7 billion, every one of those people could receive a $70,000 buyout from Congress. Double that if you want to give them two years to adjust and find new work at an electric car plant or something else. That would cost $17 billion, or less than half of what the doomed bailout of GM is going to end up costing.

And of course, with the rest of us suffering from the massive mismanagement of the nations economy by its corporate leaders and their puppets in Washington, theres no reason why our tax dollars should be subsidizing those particular workers at that high a level. After all, companies are failing and will be failing all over the place, without such largesse. Besides, if the bailout goes ahead, all it will do is delay the time these workers will be out on the street anyhow.

The point is, however, there are more cost-effective ways to help out workers in failing businesses than to have the government simply subsidize the continued operation of enterprises that have been destroyed by management. In truth, all the talk in congress and in the Obama camp about rescuing jobs is just a cover for bailouts that are really aimed at rescuing managers and investors, not workers.

 

**Articles By Dave Lindorff Accredited - Associated

More Articles From This Author...

 

 

 

 

 

Add Comments To Dave Lindorff's Articles

  Topic :: موضوع

          

 
 

Home | Site Explorer | Media Window | Writers | Fatwa Request | Bizaar | Donations | About Us | Our Sheikh | Contact Us

 
 
 
  •  

     

    للتعليم الإسلامي و الدعوة الإسلامية :: For Knowledge About Islam And Propagation Of Islam

       

     

    Awqaf Africa Muslim Open College :: كلية أوقاف إفريقيا الإسلامية المفتوحة

  •  

     

     

 

 

 

 

Director: Umm-Abdullah Adelabu Head Office admin@esinislam.com Amir (President) Sheikh Abu Abdullah Adelabu (Ph. D. Damas) sheikh@esinislam.com

 

 

 

esinislam.com 2008 Designed And Produced By Awqaf Africa London Copyright All Rights Reserved

No Copyright Permission Required For Users Whose Works, Activities, and Intentions Are for Purpose of Da'wah, Islamic Studies and Services to the Muslims

الله أكبر :: Allah Is Great

 

 

This Is EsinIslam.Com The African Muslim Portal Also Available Via IslamAfrica.Com
Your Short Cut To Illuminating Pages And Referential Files On EsinIslam Enabling You Quick And Easy Access To Rich Materials, Knowledgeable Contents And Reliable Information :: طريقك القصير إلى صفحات منيرة وملفات مرجعية على هذا الموقع تمكنك الوصول السريع والسهل إلى معارف غنية ومحتويات تعلمية ومعلومات موثوق بها
Internet Window That Gives You Instant Access To Media, Broadcasters And Publishers For Information And References Especially About The Muslim World :: نافذة الانترنت التي تمنحك الوصول الفوري الى وسائل الاعلام ، والمذيعين والناشرين للحصول على معلومات ومراجع خاصة عن العالم الاسلامي
Revenues From This Site Are Endowed To Muslim Welfare, Education And Da'wah :: مصادر الدخل لهذا الموقع وقف لرعاية المسلمين والتعليم والدعوة
<> Our Sheikh [sheikh@esinislam.com]<> Director [director@esinislam.com]<> Office [admin@esinislam.com]<> Fatwa Request [fatwas@esinislam.com]<> Donations [donations@esinislam.com]<> Counseling [counseling@esinislam.com]Or click ['Contact'] to fill a message form
We Are Awqaf Africa The Muslim Communities And A Non-Profit Making Organization Established For Dawah, Education And Relief Inside And Outside Africa :: نحن أوقاف إفريقيا المجتعات المسلمة وجمعية غير هادفة للربح موسسة للدعوة والتعليم والإسعاف
Balanced news and safe information about the Muslim World covering the Arabs, African World and beyond with pure Islamic perspectives in a way of Da'wah :: الأخبارالمتوازنة والمعلومات المأمونة عن العالم الإشلامي فيما يتضمن العرب والعالم الإفريقي وأبعد من وجهة النظر الإسلامية السليمة بشكل دعوي
The African Muslim Portal Tip