|
21 March 2010
By Stephen Lendman It's
what economist David Rosenberg calls recovery given
plenty of supportive evidence, including: --
over five million homeowners behind on their mortgage
payments; --
at record levels, foreclosures are alarmingly high;
moreover, "the foreclosure pipeline is enormous;" --
"housing, the quintessential leading indicator,"
turning lower again in starts, sales and prices; --
instead of a normal 5 - 6 months home supply, the
market has a 21 month overhang, including shadow
inventory from the foreclosure pipeline; --
mortgage applications for new home purchases down
13.9% on top of last year's 29.4%; --
over six million Americans unemployed for at least six
months, "a record 40% of the ranks of the
joblessness;" --
over 11 million full-time jobs lost since late 2007,
and well over four and a half million since Obama took
office, despite pledging to create them; --
millions of jobs lost despite massive economic
stimulus, and when it slows, watch out; -- a
federal deficit over 10% of GDP, twice the 1930s
ratio;
--private capital growing at its slowest rate in
nearly two decades; --
30% of manufacturing capacity idle; --
19 million vacant residential housing units - about
15% of the total; --
one in six Americans unemployed or underemployed; --
the adult male employment-to-population ratio at a
record low 67% compared to 73% when the recession
began; --
at this stage of the economic cycle (two and a half
years after Fed easing began), employment typically
expands at least 150,000 per month; instead, it's
still contracting, the level is 8.4 million lower than
before the recession began, and the economy is 12
million jobs shy of full employment, a gap that will
take years of sustainable growth to close; --
commercial real estate values down 30% in the past
year and falling; --
the average American worker $100,000 poorer (including
loss of home equity), even with the stock market
rally; --
bank credit contracting at an unprecedented 15% annual
rate this year "as lenders sit on a record $1.3
trillion in cash;" --
collapsed commercial and industrial loans; --
Falling Gross Domestic Income, approaching an
annualized minus 4% compared to the 1982 recessionary
low of plus 4% and 2001 low of plus 2%; "the
discrepancy between the income and spending accounts
has never been so wide as" today; and --
unit labor costs down 4.7% in the past year, meaning
workers earn and spend less.
Conclusion - "the era of 'green shoots' is officially
dead." Now you see them, now you don't because they
never were there in the first place. A
recent issue of the Economist magazine asked "Why Is
the recovery jobless? Maybe because it isn't a
recovery," with no lack of supportive evidence. "In
February, for the twenty-fifth time in 26 months, the
American economy shed jobs," and beneath the surface
it's much worse. The
official 9.7% headline number (so-called U-3; U-6,
including discouraged workers, is 16.8%) obscures the
true figure, what economist John Williams calculates
at 21.6%, minus the manipulated deception. The
Economist concludes that "the American economy simply
hasn't been doing as well as the output figures have
suggested." Take
GDP, for example. Rosenberg explains that Q 4's 5.9%
growth "came in two non-recurring items - inventories
and capital spending (the former a temporary alignment
of stocks with sales and the latter a late-year rush
to take advantage of some tax goodies)."
Those aside, the economy slowed to less than 1%, may
be revised lower, and the two headline figures won't
likely repeat, given a wealth of depressing data,
including retail sales. The headline February 0.3%
(0.8% minus autos) rise beat an expected 0.2%
decline.
However, the raw data paints a different picture -
minus 1.6% month-over-month in February (a month when
rises usually occur) or four times as bad as the norm,
and worst February in 12 years. This
(says Rosenberg) in spite of "the greatest stimulus
experience in seven decades, and retail sales are
still down 5% from the pre-recession peak and on a per
capita basis 8%." They're lower than in January 2006
despite a 4.3% larger population, and adjusted for
inflation, they're down to 1996 levels on a per capita
basis. Some
recovery, and little wonder the latest Conference
Board consumer confidence survey showed only 6.2% of
the public thinks business conditions are good - a
record low. As a
result, several presidential tracking polls have Obama
at from 44 - 49%, down from 68% in January 2009, and
for Congress it's worse at around about 30%. If
conditions worsen, expect further erosion, and if an
economic storm erupts, they may crash.
Money Creation
Madness
Through September 2008, it took the Fed nearly 14
years to double bank reserves. Bernanke did it again
in less than four months, swapping good assets for bad
ones, bank held toxic junk, but only a small fraction
of their total holdings, so the big ones remain
insolvent.
Bailouts and massive borrowing are crowding out the
private sector, making it hard to impossible for most
businesses and consumers to borrow. In his March 15
commentary titled, "The Great Credit Squeeze,"
financial expert and investor safety advocate Martin
Weiss explains the dangers: --
total government borrowing (federal, state and local)
at an annual pace of over $1 trillion; while --
businesses reduced existing debts at a near $1.1
trillion annual rate; and --
consumers virtually shut out entirely from credit
markets "cut(ting) their existing mortgages at the
annual rate of $365.1 billion and their consumer
credit at the rate of $145.3 billion," totaling an
annualized $510.4 billion cutback.
Confirming the ongoing record bank credit contraction,
"credit (overall) is actually being sucked out of the
consumer and corporate economy at a torrid pace." The
real economy is starved because of massive government
borrowing fueling a potential sovereign debt crisis
like in Iceland, Greece, and Eastern Europe, and
threatening Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Spain, the UK,
and America.
Author Niall Ferguson sees three possible Greek
outcomes, potentially affecting all heavily indebted
countries: --
"one of the most excruciating fiscal squeezes in
modern European history;
--outright default; (or) --
some kind of bailout," but he omitted the one chosen
as a long-term fix - the imposition of IMF austerity,
including deficit reduction through: --
large government layoffs; -- a
public sector 10% wage cut, including a 30% reduction
in salary entitlements; -- a
20% cut in civil service bonuses; --
freezing pensions; -- a
two-year increase in the average retirement age; --
increasing the current 19% value added tax to 21%; --
higher fuel, alcohol, tobacco, and luxury goods taxes;
and it's only the beginning with more painful measures
to come. IMF
chief economist Olivier Blanchard warns that high-debt
countries like Greece face budget squeezes for a
decade or two, requiring "painful sacrifices". Of
concern is that spreading Greek troubles threaten a
very dicey situation in Europe, America, and elsewhere
- the reason David Rosenberg calls today's crisis: "a
depression because (post-WW II) recessions were merely
small backward steps in an inventory cycle but in the
context of expanding credit. Whereas now, we are in a
prolonged period of credit contraction, especially as
it relates to households and small businesses." It's
why financial expert Bob Chapman says America's
financial system "is on the edge of default," and
public anger is growing, a recent poll showing "92% of
those surveyed wanted to unseat their current
representative or Senator....and only 21% believe that
government enjoyed the consent of the governed."
Given bipartisan criminality, a president beholden to
power, a Congress long ago bought and paid for, and
the notion of a government of, by and for the people
ludicrous, but not funny given growing unaddressed
human desperation - about to worsen when the full
Obama package becomes law, including worsening a
dysfunctional healthcare system, destroying public
education, putting the Fed (Wall Street) in charge of
financial reform and consumer protection, and imposing
IMF-style austerity.
IMF Austerity
Arriving in America It's
not coming. It's here, being incrementally rolled out,
including painful structural adjustments - some
legislated, others unavoidable like the possibility
suggested in Jonathan Laing's March 15 Bloomberg.com
article, titled "The $2 Trillion Hole" in
public-employee retirement plans.
About 80% of them are defined benefit plans, meaning
monthly payments are guaranteed, but can insolvent
states and municipalities comply, especially given
years of under-funding, fewer contributing workers at
lower pay, and continuing large budget cuts, including
mass layoffs and reduced benefits making a bad
situation worse.
Enough for University of Chicago finance professor
Robert Novy-Marx and Northwestern University's Joshua
Rauh to estimate a $3 trillion + pension funding gap
for states alone, and if economic conditions worsen,
who knows how much higher, or if millions of retirees
will, in fact, get promised benefits, despite
guarantees and taxpayers hit for the shortfall.
Corporations renege on Defined Benefit Pension Plans (DBPP)
by cutting benefits, switching to Defined Contribution
Pension Plans (DCPP), or going bankrupt and
eliminating them entirely with the help of obliging
courts. So why not states and municipalities,
especially given to how close to the edge they are,
forcing once unthinkable actions with sweeping
consequences.
What's happening regionally and locally arrived in
America from reckless policies creating unsustainable
rising debt levels - "debt peonage" for economist
Michael Hudson that "can't be repaid." It's the core
problem, and no evidence shows "countries simply grow
out of their debts," according to University of
Maryland Professor Carmen Reinhart and Harvard's
Kenneth Rogoff, or borrow their way out for Michael
Hudson. When the going gets tough, some default,
others inflate, but most rely on spending cuts and
higher taxes, making people pay for political
indiscretions - make that crimes.
Washington may impose higher taxes and devalue the
dollar, but mostly expect benefit cuts, the idea being
to end core ones including Medicare, Social Security,
eventually Medicaid, plus others millions rely on but
won't get if tough measures are enacted. Expect them.
Some are here. Others are coming through the same
structural adjustments imposed on developing countries
and just as painful and destructive.
Definitions One
calls structural adjustment programs (SAPs) "a series
of economic policies designed to reduce the role of
government," replacing its obligations with market
incentives - in other words, privatize.
BusinessDictionary.com calls it "change effected in
the basic framework of an economy by the impact of
policy reforms, such as 'liberalization' of the
economy by reducing protectionism and state
intervention" - in other words, what government does,
business does better so let it. It's
pure Chicago School fundamentalism, Milton Friedman
(1912 - 2006) its leading advocate for public wealth
in private hands, unrestrained accumulation of
profits, abolition of corporate taxes, and social
services curtailed or ended. He called economic
freedom an end to itself; opposed minimum wages,
unions and an egalitarian society; supported a flat
tax for the rich; wanted Social Security and Medicare
abolished; believed private schools should replace
public ones; wanted everyone to be on their own "free
to choose;" and called profit-making the essence of
democracy - a dark world view harmful to the majority
and devastating to the poor and disadvantaged,
characterized by SAP harshness. They
benefit capital, not people, and the more severe, the
greater the harm. They're a package of wage and
benefit cuts, mass layoffs, privatization of
government services, deregulation, de-unionization,
currency devaluation, free capital flows, market-based
pricing, free (not fair) trade, environmental harm,
and at least one other few know about. A
provision in the 2008 Farm Bill lets Washington
withhold up to 15% of Social Security and disability
benefits from anyone with outstanding government
debts, no matter how old. It applies to farm and small
business loans, unpaid or disputed taxes, health care
amounts veterans owe, and other government debt,
potentially affecting millions late in life when they
can least afford it.
Overall, the effects are devastating, including
growing poverty, inequality, the destruction of the
middle class and unions, hunger, homelessless,
environmental harm, and police state measures to quell
dissent - the essence of tyranny showing up in America
and arriving at a fast clip.
Barack Obama - Neoliberal Neocon As a
candidate, he promised change, a new course, sweeping
government reforms, addressing people needs, and "ensur(ing)
that the hopes and concerns of average Americans speak
louder in Washington than the hallway whispers of
high-priced lobbyists...." As
president, he's for business as usual, not the public.
Besides unbridled militarism, imperial wars, handouts
to the rich, shocking lawlessness, embracing torture,
political persecutions, illegal spying, and police
state rule, he ignores growing poverty, joblessness,
homelessness, human despair, and budget-strapped
states in favor of a discretionary spending freeze
from 2011 through 2013, amounting to one-sixth of the
budget. Defense, national security, and business needs
remain unconstrained. That
was his State of the Union message, followed up by
Executive Order (EO) 13531 on February 18 titled,
"National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and
Reform." In other words, soak the poor. Enrich the
wealthy, the way it always works, mostly in recent
decades, especially since 2000, and more than ever
under Obama - central casting's poster child for
power. His
EO charges the Commission with "improv(ing) fiscal
sustainability over the long run (and) balanc(ing) the
budget" by 2015, - impossible given trillion dollar +
annual deficits as far as the eye can see. Its real
aim is to dehumanize America, strip off its democratic
veneer, and transform it full-blown into Guatemala,
Honduras, or occupied Iraq, Afghanistan, or Palestine
through imposed austerity enforced by militarized
repression. As
for "fiscal responsibility," financial writer Ellen
Brown calls it fear-mongering code language for:
"delivering public monies into private hands and
raising taxes on the already-squeezed middle class,"
not a measure "to save the country from bankruptcy." She
quoted Professor Carroll Quigley from his
1966-published "Tragedy and Hope: A History of the
World in Our Time," saying:
Financial capitalism's "far-reaching aim (is) to
create a world system of financial control in private
hands able to dominate the political system of each
country and (world) economy....This system (aims for
control) in a feudalist fashion by (world) central
banks....acting in concert, by secret agreements
arrived at in frequent private meetings and
conferences." He
was prescient, former high-level government and
business insider, Catherine Austin Fitts revealing "a
financial coup d'etat," including engineering a
"fraudulent housing and debt bubble, illegally
shift(ing) vast amounts of capital" offshore, and "us(ing)
privatization as a form of piracy - a pretext to move
government assets to private investors at below-market
prices and then shift private liabilities back to
government at no cost to the private liability
holder." It's
a government-business cabal to suck wealth from the
many to the few, and from the wreckage propose reform,
meaning sweeping austerity and greater than ever top
down control, in America and globally - a cynical
scheme using populist rhetoric and "slow burn" tactics
for what Michael Parenti described in his 2002 "Global
Rollback" article, saying:
"Throughout history (ruling classes most of all have
wanted) all the choice lands, forests, game, herds,
harvests, mineral deposits and precious metals of the
earth; all the wealth, riches, and profitable returns;
all the productive facilities; all the gainful
inventiveness, and technologies; all the surplus value
produced by human labor; all the control positions of
the state and other major institutions; all public
supports and subsidies, privileges and immunities; all
the protections of the law with none of the
constraints; all the services, comforts, luxuries, and
advantages of civil society with none of the taxes and
costs. Every ruling class has wanted only this: all
the rewards and none of the burdens." As
their faithful servants, Barack Obama, Congress, and
the courts are delivering the whole package, or, in
other words, poverty for the many and unlimited wealth
and privilege for the power elite. When will enough
concerned people act in their own self interest to
stop them?
Stephen Lendman is a Research Associate of the Centre
for Research on Globalization. He lives in Chicago and
can be reached at
lendmanstephen@sbcglobal.net.
Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com and
listen to cutting-edge discussions with distinguished
guests on the Progressive Radio News Hour on the
Progressive Radio Network Thursdays at 10AM US Central
time and Saturdays and Sundays at noon. All programs
are archived for easy listening.
http://lendmennews.progressiveradionetwork.org/ |