|
17 August 2010
By Jonathan Cook
Two of the United States’
closest allies in the Middle East, Israel and Saudi
Arabia, are on the brink of signing large arms deals
with the US in a move designed to ratchet up the
pressure on Iran, according to defence analysts.
America has agreed to sell
Saudi Arabia 84 of the latest model of the F-15 jet
and dozens of Black Hawk helicopters. The deal also
includes refurbishing many of the kingdom’s older
F-15s, the Wall Street Journal reported on Monday.
Israel is believed to have
opposed the $30 billion deal. However, in a concession
to Israel, the new F-15s, made by the Boeing Company,
will not be equipped with the latest weapons and
avionics systems available to the US military.
The last such major arms
sale by the US to Saudi Arabia was in 1992, when the
kingdom received 72 F-15s. On that occasion, Israel
tried to block the $9bn deal by lobbying the US
Congress, straining relations with the White House of
George H W Bush.
Meanwhile, the US is
preparing to provide Israel’s air force with the F-35,
the latest jet fighter made by Lockheed Martin, the
Israeli daily Haaretz reported last week.
The F-35’s stealth
technology, which allows it to evade radar detection
and anti-aircraft missiles, comes with a hefty price
tag of up to $150 million a plane -- a cost that
Israel had been balking at.
But, according to the
reports, the US has offered Israeli firms defence
contracts worth $4bn to supply parts for the F-35 -- a
deal some Israeli analysts believe is designed to buy
Israel’s silence over the Saudi deal and ensure it
gets through the US Congress.
It is one of the largest
such deals in Israel’s history and it would offset
much of the cost to Israel of buying its first batch
of F-35s.
The aircraft is not
expected to enter service until 2014. If Israel signs
up for a single squadron of 20 F-35s, as expected in
the next few weeks, it would be the first country
outside the US to secure the jet. Israel has been
given an option to buy 55 more.
Last year Israel had
threatened to abandon negotiations over the F-35 and
opt instead to buy the advanced F-15. Saudi Arabia’s
reported purchase of that jet appears to make such a
scenario less likely.
The Obama administration
has faced heavy lobbying from Israel to prevent the
sale of the F-15s to Saudi Arabia.
“Today these planes are
against Iran, tomorrow they might turn against us,”
Haaretz quoted an unnamed security official as saying
last month.
Ehud Barak, Israel’s
defence minister, told the Washington Post last month
that the US administration was committed to making
sure Israel was not left in an “inferior situation”
and was “doing a lot to support Israel’s qualitative
military edge”.
The Saudis have become one
of the largest purchasers of US-made arms since they
bought the first AWACS surveillance planes in the
1980s. According to a recent Congressional report, the
Gulf kingdom spent $36 billion world-wide on arms in
the seven years to 2008.
Today, Saudi Arabia has the
third largest air force in the Middle East behind
Israel and Iran. The Royal Saudi Air Force has 280
“combat capable” aircraft, according to data compiled
by the Center for Strategic and International Studies,
compared to Israel’s 424 and Iran’s 312.
The Wall Street Journal did
not specify the model of F-15 being bought by Riyadh,
but experts widely assumed it to be the upgraded
Strike Eagle. The jet, designed for precision
air-to-surface attacks, was the main one used by the
US in destroying Iraq’s radar and missile systems
during the 2003 invasion.
Analysts said the joint
strengthening of the Saudi Arabian and Israeli
militaries was seen as a key regional interest for the
US, given the belief in Washington that Iran is
seeking to develop a nuclear warhead and is rapidly
amassing a large arsenal of missiles.
If, as Iran reportedly
claimed last week, it is in possession of Russian
S-300 anti-aircraft missiles, the F-35 stealth
technology would give Israel an important advantage in
an attack.
However, some analysts have
questioned the wisdom of the US arms sales.
Trita Parsi, an analyst at
the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington and an expert
on Israeli-Iranian relations, said it was a “misguided
policy” aimed at keeping Tehran “isolated and
subdued”.
“All that is achieved by
heavily arming Arab states and Israel is to increase
Iran’s sense of insecurity and therefore make the
region less secure,” he said.
Stephen Zunes, a US-based
Middle East policy analyst, accused Washington of
setting the stage for another “arms race” in the
region.
“This is a pattern we’ve
seen before. The US offers Arab states expensive
modern armaments, and then turns around to Israel and
tells it it needs to have even better weapons to stay
ahead in the race. Then the pressure again mounts on
the Arab states. It’s a racket that has been a bonanza
for US arms manufacturers,” he said.
Israel receives $3bn
annually in US military aid, more than any other
country and covering about a quarter of Israel’s
defence expenditure. Unlike other recipients, Israel
is allowed to spend 26 per cent of the aid on the
development and production of its own weapons
systems.
However, Israeli officials
are reported to fear that a combined squeeze on the
country’s defence budget and a massive outlay on
buying a large number of F-35s would leave the
military without money to replenish its stocks of
ammunition and bombs.
Last month Washington
agreed to an additional military subsidy of $420
million to help Israel develop its “missile shield”
programmes, designed to intercept short-, mid- and
long-range missiles.
Israel has been concerned
by the growing stockpiles of rockets and missiles that
Hamas and Hizbullah have accumulated close to its
borders as well as the more advanced arsenals of Iran
and Syria.
In addition to the question
of the price of the F-35, Israel and the US have been
at loggerheads over whether Israel should be allowed
to install its own avionics and weapons systems. So
far the US has refused, and last month denied Israel a
test aircraft.
In the past, Tel Aviv and
Washington have fallen out over Israel copying and
selling on American systems to other regimes.
Jonathan Cook is a
writer and journalist based in Nazareth, Israel. His
latest books are “Israel and the Clash of
Civilisations: Iraq, Iran and the Plan to Remake the
Middle East” (Pluto Press) and “Disappearing
Palestine: Israel's Experiments in Human Despair” (Zed
Books). His website is
www.jkcook.net. |