|
11 December 2010 By Keith Johnson George Orwell coined the phrase "double speak" in
his science fiction classic "1984." According to
Wikipedia: double speak is language that
deliberately disguises, distorts, or reverses the
meaning of words. Some examples from the book
are: War is Peace The latest example of this technique being used
comes to us courtesy of ADL head, Abraham Foxman, who
recently condemed former White House journalist, Helen
Thomas, for statements she made in a speech delivered
to a group of Arab American students at the University
of Dearborn last Thursday. In that speech, Thomas
made this truthful and factual assessment of the
political reality dominating our society: "We are owned by the propagandists against the
Arabs. There's no question about that. Congress, the
White House and Hollywood, Wall Street, are owned by
the Zionists. No question in my opinion. They put
their money where their mouth is. ... We're being
pushed into a wrong direction in every way." Foxman responded by stating: "Helen Thomas has clearly, unequivocally
revealed herself as a vulgar anti-Semite. Her
suggestion that Zionists control government, finance
and Hollywood is nothing less than classic,
garden-variety anti-Semitism. This is a sad final
chapter to an otherwise illustrious career. Unlike her
previous, spontaneous remarks into a camera, these
words were carefully thought out and conscious. It
shows a prejudice that is deep-seated and obssessive." How do you like them apples? Here we have a white
man—born to Eastern European parents—calling a Semitic
person an anti-Semite. If that's not double speak, I
don't know what is. That's right. Helen Thomas is a true, honest to
goodness Semite. She is of Lebanese decent, which
makes her Arab Semitic. Even today, most dictionaries define the word
"Semite" as: a member of a group of
Semitic-speaking peoples of the Near East and northern
Africa, including the Arabs, Arameans, Babylonians,
Carthaginians, Ethiopians, Hebrews, and Phoenicians. Is Foxman a Semite? I'm not so sure.
We do know that he was born to Polish parents in a
town that once belonged to Poland, but is now part of
the Republic of Belarus in Eastern Europe. According
to his biography, posted on the ADL website: "Born in Poland in 1940, Mr. Foxman was saved
from the Holocaust as an infant by his Polish Catholic
nanny who baptized and raised him as a Catholic during
the war years. His parents survived the war, but 14
members of his family were lost." That hardly makes him a Semite—according to our
academic definition—unless of course there is
something about his background that we don't know
about. Can his ancestry be traced back to the Middle
East, or do his ancestors hail from the plains of
southern Russia and the Caucasus Mountains, where many
Jewish Poles are more often linked to the Khazars of
Central Asia, who converted to Judaism in the late
seventh and early eighth centuries? Though raised a Catholic, Foxman now identifies
with Judaism. But Judaism does not make you a
Semite. Judaism makes you Jewish, Scientology makes
you a Scientologist, and Christianity makes you a
Christian. We're talking about a belief system here,
not genetics. Of course many Judaists will disagree. They
believe that their Jewishness constitutes a genetic
bloodline that can be traced back to the legendary
Abraham of the Old Testament. They even claim that
certain genetic studies have proven this to be a
scientific fact. But these studies are sponsored by
Judaists, authored by Judaists, and are conducted at
Jewish institutions. Their papers are released with
misleading titles that are picked up by ignorant
journalists who propagate conclusions that the real
studies have never reached. Not one study has been
able to find a gene that is unique to Jews.
The reason they don't is because no two people
share the same version of the human genome text except
pairs of identical twins. These studies are full of
flaws and distortions using data that does not fit the
theory they set out to prove. Still, many Judaists insist that they are direct
descendants of a Jewish people that received the Torah
in Sinai. They maintain that their exile from the
"Promised Land" set them on a two thousand year
journey of wandering throughout much of the world, and
that they always managed to preserve that crucial
bloodline that links that them to the children of
Abraham. Israeli historian, Shlomo Sand, author of the book,
"The Invention of the Jewish People," has done
a thorough job of debunking some of the more widely
propagated myths in support of this Jewish Diaspora.
His
research is supported by archaeological evidence
discovered—following an earthquake in the 1980's—that
discredits the great exodus of the 13th
century B.C., among other things. "Moses could not have led the Hebrews out of
Egypt into the Promised Land, for the good reason that
the latter was Egyptian territory at the time. And
there is no trace of either a slave revolt against the
pharaonic empire or of a sudden conquest of Canaan by
outsiders. Nor is there any trace or memory of the
magnificent kingdom of David and Solomon. Recent
discoveries point to the existence, at the time, of
two small kingdoms: Israel, the more powerful, and
Judah, the future Judea. The general population of
Judah did not go into 6th century BC exile: only its
political and intellectual elite were forced to settle
in Babylon. This decisive encounter with Persian
religion gave birth to Jewish monotheism. Then there is the question of the exile of
70 AD. There has been no real research into this
turning point in Jewish history, the cause of the
diaspora. And for a simple reason: the Romans never
exiled any nation from anywhere on the eastern
seaboard of the Mediterranean. Apart from enslaved
prisoners, the population of Judea continued to live
on their lands, even after the destruction of the
second temple. Some converted to Christianity in the
4th century, while the majority embraced Islam during
the 7th century Arab conquest." As you can see, there is much to suggest that many
people who refer to themselves as Semites are doing so
incorrectly. But, of course, we're still defining
Semites according to the academic standard. If you
define a Semite within the context of anti-Semitism,
you get a whole other story altogether. What is anti-Semitism? According to the ADL
website, anti-Semitism is: "The belief or behavior hostile toward Jews
just because they are Jewish. It may take the form of
religious teachings that proclaim the inferiority of
Jews, for instance, or political efforts to isolate,
oppress, or otherwise injure them. It may also include
prejudiced or stereotyped views about Jews." Two European writers from the late 19th
century, Wilhelm Marr and Heinrich Von Treitschke, are
the ones often credited with applying the word Semite
exclusively to Jews. But I reject this notion. Am I
allowed to do that, or am I forced to accept the
assumptions of two self proclaimed anti-Semites? I don't know about you, but I prefer to apply the
word Semite to a wide range of Semitic speaking people
from the Near East and northern Africa,
including the Arabs, Arameans, Babylonians,
Carthaginians, Ethiopians, Hebrews, and Phoenicians. If you want my definition of anti-Semitism, I would
refer you to what is being done to the people of
Gaza. That's anti-Semitism on steroids. I would also apply the term anti-Semitism to the
growing Islamophobia taking place here in the United
States and in parts of Europe. The Iraq war was anti-Semitic, as is the war in
Afghanistan as well as what is being planned against
the people of Iran. The ADL is anti-Semitic. When plans were announced
to build an Islamic community center blocks away from
Ground Zero, Abe Foxman came out against it. Some
called old Abe out for his hypocrisy on that one. And
although he has recently tried to repair the ADL's
image by condemning certain acts carried out against
Muslims, he continues to feed the flames of racism and
bigotry (behind the scenes) by allowing his group to
be allied with organizations like "Family Security
Matters" (FSM), a fiercely anti-Islamic group that
propagates lies and peddles in fear and loathing
against Muslims. "Family Security Matters (FSM) originated in 2003 as a project of the Center for Security Policy a hawkish security policy think tank and advocacy group. Soon after its formation FSM claimed to represent "security moms". While generally supportive of President George W. Bush's domestic and international security policies, FSM have had their differences with the Republican administration over issues such as immigration policy, U.S. policy towards Russian Presdient Vladimir Putin. Since the Democratic ascendancy in the 2006 mid-term elections, FSM have also published criticisms of the Bush administration -- such as those byNewt Gingrich -- for being too cautious in their strategy in the Middle East. FSM states on its website that its mission is to "inform all Americans, men and women, about the issues surrounding national security; to address their fears about safety and security on a personal, family, community, national and international level; to highlight the connection between individual safety and a strong national defense; to increase civic participation and political responsibility; and to empower all Americans to become proactive defenders of our national security and community safety." And Media Matters says this in an article from 2004 entitled "FOX's "security mom" expert spouted Bush-Cheney talking points" "Family Security Matters (FSM) is a front group front for the Center for Security Policy (CSP), a conservative Washington think tank think "committed to the time-tested philosophy of promoting international peace through American strength." (The phone number listed on the FSM website is answered by the CSP.) The FSM website features articles by, among others, right-wing syndicated columnist Michelle Malkin Michelle and CSP president Frank J. Gaffney Jr., whose lies and distortions Media Matters for America has documented." If we were to take the ADL's definition of anti-Semitism, and replace the word "Jews" with "Muslims," you would find that FSM fits those criteria to a "T." Let's try it. What is anti-Semitism? "The belief or behavior hostile toward Muslims just because they are Muslim. It may take the form of religious teachings that proclaim the inferiority of Muslims, for instance, or political efforts to isolate, oppress, or otherwise injure them. It may also include prejudiced or stereotyped views about Muslims." Want proof of their anti-Semitism? Take a look at some of these excerpts, taken from articles that FSM runs on its website: From "What is Islam?" "Islam is a comprehensive totalitarian form of slavery. It is the opposite of freedom. Its very name, Islam means submission or surrender. True to its name, Islam strives for nothing short of enslavement of the body of humanity as well as the bondage of its mind. This non-negotiable surrender to Islam requires the individual, as well as the society, to disenfranchise themselves of many of the fundamental and deeply cherished human rights." "Islam is not a religion, but a harmful thorn; thus, we must make laws to fight this unwanted thorn growing like mushrooms in our backyards. If Islam is not controlled, these mushrooms soon will blossom and become mushroom-clouds." From "Islam—Phobia or Simple Misunderstanding?" "The problem we face at the Mosque and elsewhere is not one of moderate Islam versus an extreme or perverted version. The problem is with the fundamental nature of Islam itself. Read the Koran, listen to the Imams. One need not be selective in the passages he chooses, just try to understand what the Koran is commanding the faithful to do. For anyone who still has doubts after that, play back the tape of millions of wildly cheering Muslims from Cairo to London after the 9/11 attacks." From "Why Would a Woman Convert to Islam?" "…as so many autobiographies of Muslim women note, the religion bans anything that is fun ("haram"or forbidden). No chewing of gum, no bicycle riding, no make-up, no eating in public, no painting of nails, no pets, no questions, and of course, no answering back. For many Muslim women, there is an eagerness to assert independence as soon as adulthood is reached." "By and large, Islam devolves into extremism, the repression of women, inequality, and brutality such as the stoning of adulterers. Converts, however, refer to the celebration of old-fashioned family values and hospitality, values which have been eroded in the West. For many, Islam is an escape route from the cultural degradation of Western society. But what converts often confuse is culture and religion. The warmth a family confers is not the same as the demands of religious obedience." This is just a sampling. There are plenty more. I would challenge you to browse their website and find at least one article sympathetic to Muslims. So what is the ADL's connection to this group? Well, the Executive Vice President is Linda G. Cohen, who also serves as a trustee on the New Mexico Board of the Anti-Defamation League. No wonder we don't find this organization listed among the many radical-right groups being monitored by the Southern Poverty Law Center. So who are the real anti-Semites? I guess that all depends on whom you ask. Unfortunately, nobody is asking me. |