|
09 December 2010 By Osman Mirghani The disclosure of a new batch of classified
American documents via ‘Wikileaks' has caused a great
sir across the world. Although the site has been in
existence for approximately three years, a lot of
people were unaware of it, until classified U.S.
documents began to be leaked, firstly regarding
military operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, and most
recently U.S. diplomatic activity. The documents
contained embarrassing information, regarding the U.S.
administration, and how it perceives a number of world
leaders, including the heads of state of several
allies. The leaked memos detail views stated during
meetings between US diplomats, and several world
leaders. They also reveal instructions issued by the
U.S. Department of State to its diplomats abroad,
requesting them to obtaining intelligence and personal
information about foreign officials and international
organizations. The controversy will go on for some time,
especially if we consider the magnitude of the leaked
documents, consisting of over 250,000 cables exchanged
between 274 embassies, diplomatic missions, and
consulates around the world, in correspondence with
the United States. The memos are dated up to the end
of February 2010, and are not written in conventional
diplomatic language. The correspondence took place
behind closed doors, and those involved did not expect
such documents to be publicly released in the near
future. But is it worth all this fuss? The documents, without question, shed light on
important issues, and they might even bring about a
change in some diplomatic practices. However, they are
unlikely to lead to any substantial change in U.S.
strategic goals and policies, or even in the relations
between the U.S. and its allies mentioned in the
documents. Everyone is aware that a fundamental task
of embassies around the world is to submit reports to
their native foreign ministries. Every country expects
its embassies to provide it with reports on issues
that affect its interests, or in some cases to
secretly gather intelligence. Regardless of the information revealed in the
documents, and the controversy they have caused, there
is a fact which cannot be ignored: diplomatic work
cannot be entirely transparent. Bilateral relations
between countries require talks behind closed doors.
Otherwise, talks between allies would be revealed to
their foes, in an increasingly entangled world. When some politicians criticise ‘Wikileaks', they
tend to forget that the harm done to diplomatic
relations does not come from this website alone. Many
western politicians, after they have left office, have
tended to disclose some of what took place during
secret talks with leaders and officials. We have seen
examples of this with George W.Bush and Tony Blair,
who revealed such information as a means of promoting
their memoirs, for which they are paid millions of
dollars. However, events are not usually recorded in
this way, for history is much better suited to
historians than politicians. We can be certain that the publication of these
documents, in addition to the earlier leaks related to
the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan; will have a lasting
impact on information security, and ways of dealing
with online documents. This was highlighted by
Christopher Mayer, former British Ambassador to the
United States during the term of Tony Blair. Although
he said that these documents will not prevent
diplomats from disclosing their views via cables to
their governments, as it is their duty, he stated that
such leaks would make governments pay more attention
to the issue of information security, and the
confidentiality of online documents. This is exactly what Washington has done, having
announced the day before yesterday that it has
provided instructions to its governmental bodies to
handle classified information with utmost strictness.
The U.S. has also placed restrictions on the
information available to each employee, so that no one
has access to anything other than what they need in
order to do their job. The challenge won't be easy, especially considering
that the military official accused of transferring
these classified documents to ‘Wikileaks', revealed in
an online chat discussion, obtained by the US
authorities after his arrest, that the whole process
was like ‘child's play' to him. He would go to work,
as a data analyst, carrying a CD with music on it,
before deleting the music files and recording
classified information instead. To further mislead any
potential surveillance, he would play songs via his
mobile phone, giving the impression he was listening
to the music on his CD, which he had inserted into his
computer to obtain the classified information. Finally, we should be cautious when dealing with
leaks, even if they are proven to be official
documents, as is the case with the U.S. government
cables, whose authenticity has not been disputed by
the Obama Administration. The controversy surrounds
how such information was leaked, and the purpose that
it serves. ‘Wikileaks' has always been selective about
what information it posts, when it posts it, and what
parts it chooses to highlight. The leaked documents
may help us see the overall picture, yet for a clear
interpretation, we must move away from the present
climate of suspicion. |