Why Did The Government Fail To Win Over The Tunisians? Old Habits Die Hard
18 January 2011
By Abdul Rahman Al-Rashid
What we are talking about here
has become a well known fact: It is impossible to
control today's new media with the instruments of the
old system. It is true that this is one of the axioms
of the modern day, but as the saying goes, "old habits
die hard". This is why the Tunisian government failed
to confront its crisis. Those in power did not realize
that the state-run media's audience had diminished
over the past few years, to the extent that government
information now had barely any influence on mainstream
opinion. The old system had lost its captivation due
to the emergence of the mass electronic media.
We can also draw an analogy here with public taste
in general. In the past, a singer in Tunisia would not
have been accredited as such unless they had first
passed an official radio test, and had been approved
by a panel of around three judges. Afterwards, they
would be officially recognized by the state as a
recording artist, and thus would be broadcasted to
millions. At that time, the broadcasting commission,
or the individual in charge, determined the musical
taste of the entire nation. They would decide on the
singer, and ratify the lyrics and the music. As a
result, only a handful of recording artists were
approved every decade or so.
Today, we find performers, who have been banned
from appearing on national television, registering
over two million downloads and hits on the internet.
This is an astronomical figure compared to the past,
when the most famous recording artists would only sell
several thousand cassette tapes. Today there are
literally hundreds of public performers, who are
widely acclaimed. No one could impose a song or melody
upon them, or indeed ban them anymore, despite
complaints voiced by state officials regarding the
‘dominance of low-standard entertainment'. Yet these
officials are complaining because the decision is no
longer in their hands. Whilst the media apparatus has
definitely changed, some minds are still thinking and
functioning in the same old fashion.
President Ben Ali's government was once proud to
claim that Tunisia was the first country [in the
region] to use the internet. This is true to some
extent, but the government utilised it as a means of
transmitting messages, rather than a genuine two-way
process. The internet is more than just a new
technology, it is a new concept. Yet the Tunisian
government approached it as it had done with the state
radio, television, and press. They created websites
for the official press agency, the President and the
government, and broadcasted state television over the
internet. This was deemed as upgrading to the modern
media!
In my opinion, Tunisia's promise to open up to the
outside world came too late, as millions of internet
users had heard, seen and read contrasting facts for
years. I can't imagine how a few presidential decrees
could change peoples' beliefs so quickly and so
easily. Ben Ali, just like Tunisia's old singers,
believed that the broadcasting commission was
responsible for the performer, the music and the
lyrics. After four decisive weeks he discovered how
wrong he was. By ignoring accusations levelled at the
government, and popular demands, no matter how much he
deemed them to be incorrect or impractical, President
Ben Ali widened the gap between the government and the
people. It just takes one angry citizen to fire their
gun in public, in order to prompt others to do the
same.
The Tunisian scenario represents a clash between
two different cultures, within one country. The
Tunisian President did all that was expected from him
in terms of crisis management. Firstly, he
acknowledged the existence of a problem, and then
announced that he had taken the public's message on
board. As a result, he promised to provide employment
opportunities, as per the public demand. Then, he
threw a number of ministers and assistants in front of
the crowds, as scapegoats. Finally, he declared his
intention to end his long period of rule upon
completing his current term in office. He also
retracted earlier policies, by reopening internet
sites and news services which had previously been
blocked and banned. Ben Ali could have spared himself
all these concessions had he understood and responded
to what was being said and discussed on the internet
over the past few years. Ben Ali should have opened up
the traditional state-run media, in order to keep pace
with the popular electronic format. He should have
adopted a transparent approach to solving problems in
a timely manner, and not after there has been a public
uprising.
Al Rashed is the general manager of Al -Arabiya television. He is also the
former editor-in-chief of Asharq Al- Awsat, and the leading Arabic weekly
magazine, Al Majalla. He is also a senior Columnist in the daily newspapers of
Al Madina and Al Bilad. He is a US post-graduate degree in mass communications.
He has been a guest on many TV current affairs programs. He is currently based
in Dubai.