|
08 January 2011
By Jacob G. Hornberger Within two days of being sworn into office,
congressional Republicans are already breaking their
promises with respect to out-of-control federal
spending and borrowing. In their much-ballyhooed
"Pledge to America" they promised to cut $100 billion
out of non-defense discretionary spending during their
first year in office. House Republican leaders, having
now taken control of the House, have just announced
that that isn't going to happen after all. Did I not tell you this, long before the election?
As I have long emphasized, there isn't a dime's worth
of difference between a Democrat and a Republican (or,
if you will, a liberal and a conservative). Sure,
Republicans use libertarian mantras (i.e., "free
enterprise, private property, and limited government")
and rail against excessive federal spending and
borrowing, but it's all fake and false — just a way to
get hold of the reins of power, so that they can start
enriching themselves at the trough. Isn't that what
they did after they made similar promises with their
much ballyhooed "Contract with America" in 1994? Look at all the brouhaha over Obamacare. House
Republicans are making a big deal out of plans to
repeal Obamacare. Big deal. What difference would it
make? Republicans know that the Senate won't go along
and even if it did, everyone knows that Obama will
simply veto it and that the veto won't be overridden
by Congress. It's all about just making a show — "Look
at what we're doing about excessive spending and
borrowing and federal regulation by voting to repeal
Obamacare." More important, even if Obamacare were to be
repealed, the country would still be left with the
health-care crisis that is rooted in Medicare and
Medicaid. That crisis wouldn't disappear with the
repeal of Obamacare. The mainstream press would be
(and already is) screaming to Republicans, "Where is
your plan to fix and improve our health care system?"
And since Republicans believe in Medicare and
Medicaid, they would be left with coming up with some
sort of interventionist fix-it reform that would
simply be a variation of Obamacare and that would make
the situation worse than ever. The fundamental problem is that Republicans
(conservatives), like Democrats (liberals), honestly
believe that the legitimate role of the federal
government is to take care of people through a welfare
state. That's what Social Security, Medicare,
Medicaid, food stamps, education grants, foreign aid,
FDIC, bank bailouts, and other welfare-state programs
are all about — taking care of people. Republicans are
not about to challenge the moral legitimacy of that
paradigm or its programs. Yet, it is these programs — that is, it's the
welfare state itself (and the warfare state) — that is
at the root of America's economic woes. Thus, the only
solution is to rid our nation of the welfare-state
paradigm itself (and the warfare-state paradigm). That's what makes us libertarians so different from
conservatives and liberals and other statists. We want
to ditch the welfare-warfare paradigm in favor of one
based on individual liberty, free markets, and a
constitutional republic. That necessarily means repeal
and dismantling, not reform and improvement. Consider the title of this editorial from Tuesday's
Los Angeles Times: "Their Job is to Create
Jobs." That's the mainstream mindset. It's the mindset
of conservatives, liberals, and other statists. These
types of people honestly believe that it's the job of
the federal government to manage the economy, create
jobs, and take care of people. That's the problem. Do you see how different we libertarians are from
statists? We don't believe that government has any
more business managing the economy and creating jobs
than it does managing religion and stimulating
interest in God. The root of America's economic woes
lies in the fact that the federal government is
charged with the power to do such things as manage the
economy, create jobs, fight poverty, take care of
people, and dominate and control the world. The solution to America's economic woes lies in
removing the power of the government to manage the
economy, create jobs, fight poverty, and police the
world. Prosperity lies in the freedom of people to
engage in enterprise freely with people all over the
world (i.e., without government interference),
accumulate unlimited amounts of wealth (i.e., no more
federal income tax and IRS), and decide for themselves
what to do with their own money (i.e., no more Social
Security, Medicare, Medicaid, welfare, etcetera). The
solution to America's woes lies with libertarian
principles. Too bad House Republicans (with the
exception of Ron Paul) are still so committed to
statism. Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of The
Future of Freedom Foundation. |