Re: The case of Dr. Tarek Mehanna - The Prosecution, The Defense

24 February 2011

By El-Hajj Mauri' Saalakhan 

Assalaamu Alaikum (Greetings of Peace): 

Boston, MA - The latest chapter in yet another preemptive prosecution case, targeting an American-born Muslim, unfolded February 23rd at a federal courthouse in Boston, MA. The government's case against Tarek Mehanna is now almost three years old. (At this writing Tarek has been in pre-trial solitary detention for 491 days).  

The case essentially began (in the collective mind of many) when Tarek was approached by the FBI to work for the agency as a spy in the Muslim community, and refused. In the mind of the "minders," the operative principle kicked in (if you're not with us, you're against us) and the rest, as they say, is history.  

There is an official narrative of the case, which can be found in the government's indictment of this young Muslim, and in most of what has been written about the case in the mainstream media. To get a more accurate picture of the case, however, and the equally important peripheral issues surrounding it, one should read what Tarek Mehanna's supporters have to say about it. 

Toward this end, the following website has been established in his defense. (Snapshots on a number of other Muslim political prisoners in America can be found on this website as well.)  

http://www.freetarek.com/  

What follows is a summary of the notes taken by this writer at the February 23rd hearing.  

The arguments made by Tarek's lawyers (Janice Bassil and Sejal Patel) were excellent. Bassil spoke about Tarek's impeccable personal history - i.e. his educational achievement and spiritual growth, and of the views that he expoused as constitutionally protected speech (even when he expoused views that were "crude" to say the least). "This case is paper thin," she argued. 

Bassil spoke of how Tarek's parents had put up their home to secure his first release on bond, and how they would be willing to do it again. 

She argued that the photos the government is using to make a circumstantial case against Tarek -photos allegedly taken from Tarek's computer - are photos that he didn't download himself. (But even if he had, it would again constitute "protected speech.") 

She also touched upon the fact that a number of prominent non-Muslim personalities in the international community were once viewed as "terrorists" by their adversaries. When she mentioned Menachim Begin's name (the former prime minister of Israel), I reflected on how he reportedly glorified in being a terrorist. According to reports he would begin many of his speeches proudly declaring the fact that, "I am a former terrorist."  

(We also have the example of South Africa's Nelson Mandela; who was NOT a terrorist, but a proud freedom fighter, and one of the leading statesmen in the world today!)  

The purpose of the hearing was to determine if Tarek should receive bond, and be allowed to live at home until a jury of his peers determines his fate.  

The prosecution 

The prosecution argued that Tarek's past interest in traveling overseas should result in his being considered a "flight risk," and that his "admiration of Osama bin Laden," and his embrace of the Islamic doctrine of jihad, should result in him being considered "a danger to the community." 

"This case is about Muslim youth being radicalized by foreign Muslims," the prosecutor argued, as he emphasized the overseas trips that Tarek allegedly took in a failed attempt to join a terrorist group. The prosecutor also referenced the "Muslim scholars" that Tarek "came under the influence of," who preached ""offensive jihad." (I found this reference to "offensive jihad" as opposed to a blanket definition of jihad interesting.) 

The prosecutor also referenced the website that's been established by Tarek's supporters, as he attempted to cite material from it (without the requisite specificity, in my view) to support the government's case against Tarek; and most immediately, the government's opposition to him being released on bond. 

The defense

The defense came back, this time in the person of Sejal Patel, with their position on why Tarek warranted release on bond. She argued that in addition to the points made by Ms. Bassil, Tarek's release would allow him to assist in a more substantive way in his own defense (an argument opposed by the government of course). She underscored the murkiness of the government's case against Tarek, emphasizing the fact that the weight of ambiguity surrounding the case makes a constitutionally guaranteed defense extremely difficult. 

Disturbingly typical was the fact that nothing this writer heard in the government's arguments was materially illegal. The government's case appears to be solely based on an assembly and manipulation of circumstantial evidence, all pointing to (in the government's estimation) an intent to commit an act of terrorism. 

The defense requested exculpatory evidence from the government (an all too frequent request in cases of this nature). They argued that 86 requests have been made to government prosecutors in the case, with a rather tepid response to only 12 of those requests to date. A related question was also raised, as to if and when defense counsel would receive the requisite "security clearance" to be able to review more of the government's "evidence" against their client. 

On final note: 

An estimated 100 supporters (Muslims and non-Muslims) filled the large courtroom where the proceeding was held, with a significant number of additional supporters observing the proceeding in an overflow room over a video monitor. The hearing was also attended by quite a bit of street theater, with a number of heavily armed police (some with dogs) parading around the perimeter of the courthouse from start to finish. 

For our part, we emphasized and encouraged (in brief remarks to the media outside the courthouse) that those who were present to hear the arguments from both sides, objectively reflect on the arguments made and report fairly on what transpired. I was pleased to note that in early mainstream media reporting the coverage was indeed fair and balanced.

 

With that said, what follows are four,

ed reports/commentaries on this very disturbing case. In addition to these there are also a number of broadcast reports on yesterday's proceedings.

 

©  EsinIslam.Com

Add Comments






© EsinIslam.Com Designed & produced by The Awqaf London. Please pray for us