|
25 August 2012 By Abdul Rahman Al-Rashed Because Egyptian President
Mohammed Mursi is going through his honeymoon period,
we did not expect him to bare his teeth at the
Egyptian press; he has mostly indulged journalists and
handled them gently. This cordial relationship was to
be expected at the beginning of his presidency, for
Mursi cannot be blamed for the 30 year legacy he has
inherited from his predecessor Hosni Mubarak. Hence we
were stunned when Islam Afifi, editor of al-Dustour
newspaper, was dragged to court on charges of
insulting the President and inciting against him, even
for a news item that was written before Mursi assumed
the presidency! Everyone is waiting for the court's verdict, which
is expected at the end of the month. If Afifi is
sentenced to prison we will witness a fierce battle
emerging, because the media in Egypt is actually more
vicious than the military. No matter how Mursi uses
his powers to prosecute his critics, in the end he
will discover what Mubarak discovered before him, who
in the end was forced to keep silent grudgingly
because he had failed to muzzle the media. He tried
many means, including jail sentences on more than one
occasion. He paid huge rewards to those who had made
their name in the independent camp and then moved on
to work in the official state media institution, but
even this did not succeed in silencing them. Mursi and those alongside him in the Egyptian
leadership are used to sitting in the chairs of the
opposition and are not familiar yet with the downsides
of being in governance, including press criticism. The Egyptian media is known for its loud voice.
Today, and ever since the January 25th revolution last
year, it has begun to monopolize the market. The
Egyptian media is now at the forefront, whereas in the
past the domain was somewhat mixed. The secret lies in
the high ceiling of freedom after the ouster of the
Mubarak regime, so how will Mursi manage to get the
genie back in the bottle? How can the new Egyptian
President tame the Egyptian press, which has become an
important figure in the political and social process?
Mursi, or his party, succeeded and hired loyalists in
the national – i.e. government – media institution,
which accounts for about fifty newspapers and
magazines, but in Egypt there are around 120 other
licensed independent media outlets, and there are
7,000 journalists registered in the union.
Furthermore, how does Mursi intend to silence the
great army of social network users, where about 10
million Egyptians take part in debates using Facebook,
Twitter and mobile phone messaging, capable of
unsettling the Egyptian President at any point until
the end of his reign? In the final years of Mubarak's rule it was no
secret that the relationship between him and the
Egyptian media had descended to its lowest level. We,
as media figures operating outside the country, could
sense the ill feeling. At one point Anas el-Fiqqi,
Mubarak's obedient Minister of Information, tried to
pursue a number of foreign media outlets, even
travelling outside Egypt and confronting them.
According to el-Fiqqi, Mubarak had objected to such
outlets, saying: Why does the opposition appear on
foreign screens, and why are they discussing Egyptian
issues? El-Fiqqi informed him that Egypt was a big
country regionally, too big to prevent others from
covering its events. Likewise, Mubarak did not have
guardianship over foreign media outlets, and anything
that was mentioned in the foreign press was reiterated
by the independent Egyptian media itself anyway.
Furthermore, each of these so-called opponents, whom
Mubarak demanded to be removed from foreign screens,
were either members of the People's Assembly, held
valid media licenses or worked in licensed newspapers.
Mubarak was simply trying to control the foreign media
after he had failed to silence the Egyptian media. This was Mubarak, while Mursi should remember that
his legitimacy is based on freedom and pluralism, so
how is it possible that one of the first decisions of
his era is to imprison a journalist and close a
television station?
Al Rashed is the general manager of Al -Arabiya
television. He is also the former editor-in-chief of
Asharq Al- Awsat, and the leading Arabic weekly
magazine, Al Majalla. He is also a senior Columnist in
the daily newspapers of Al Madina and Al Bilad. He is
a US post-graduate degree in mass communications. He
has been a guest on many TV current affairs programs.
He is currently based in Dubai. |