What Have We Learned From Fareed
Zakaria? Comments, "Don't Be Sad"
22 August 2012
By Mshari al-Zaydi
Last week an important story emerged that every
Arab journalist and columnist should closely monitor.
This is a story that teaches a valuable lesson whilst
also representing a stern warning regarding the ethics
governing a career in the media, or indeed writing in
general.
In summary, the story is that US media "star"
Fareed Zakaria had plagiarized passages in his article
for "Time" magazine on gun control in the US from
another writer.
An internet website revealed this case of
plagiarism, which was limited to certain paragraphs,
not the entire article. The news spread widely, but
Zakaria was not obstinate and promptly offered an
apology to "Time" magazine, which temporarily
suspended him. Zakaria was also suspended by CNN,
where he presents his famous television show, as well
as the Washington Post.
It is noticeable that despite the heavyweight
nature of the institutes where Zakaria works, not to
mention his own personal fame, knowledge and history
as a journalist, these were all of no assistance to
him after he violated the ethical and professional
values that rule his career.
The best comment that I read on the Fareed Zakaria
incident was written by American critic and columnist
David Zurawik. Zurawik said that it was no surprise
that there was an instant and decisive punishment
regarding Zakaria's actions This is because
"plagiarism used to be a deadly journalistic sin from
which there often was no redemption." The internet has
made numerous sources of information readily
available, and this may allure some writers to simply
copy and paste without attribution, however –at the
same time – the internet has made it easier to expose
those who plagiarize.
Yes, this discreditable conduct has spread widely
because of the deteriorating standards of writing, not
to mention the media in general, as well as the
proliferation of media outlets. Let us set aside
Twitter, Facebook and personal blogs from this
discussion, for these represent a separate issue, and
only look at television and print media, particularly
as such media today contain standards and practices
that would have been inconceivable in the past.
According to critic David Zurawik, the main cause
of this is the lack of ethical values in journalism,
not to mention the ease provided by the internet.
Hence, in terms of writing and analysis, there are
writers who are "masters" of their field and those who
know nothing. There are writers who know all the
faucets of a story's background and significance, and
those who do not. There are writers who know history,
and those who do not. Therefore any writer who is
merely seeking fame need only click on "Google" to be
met with a sea of information which they can take
without attribution or even necessary being aware of
all the story's dimensions. This, however, results in
an unfair parity between an informed person and an
uniformed one, at least superficially.
The crux of the matter, in my assessment, lies in
the mad rush for fame and fortune, self-exaggeration
and deteriorating standards of writing, confusion
between uninformed typing and well-informed and
well-thought out writing.
We live in a time of ease and comfort. Yet, Fareed
Zakaria's lesson may serve as an alarm for those among
us who are not of the same journalistic quality as
him, but are nevertheless plagiarizing far more than
he did and are still held in high esteem by societies
that seem indifferent to the crucial need to exclude
those who transgress the value of the word, not to
mention their own ethical integrity.
Allow me to conclude by quoting well-known Saudi
writer Khalaf al-Harbi's comments on this particular
issue, "don't be sad."
A Saudi journalist
and expert on Islamic movements and Islamic
fundamentalism as well as Saudi affairs. Mshari is
Asharq Al-Awsat's opinion page Editor, where he also
contributes a weekly column. Has worked for the local
Saudi press occupying several posts at Al -Madina
newspaper amongst others. He has been a guest on
numerous news and current affairs programs as an
expert on Islamic extremism.