22 December 2012By Abdul Rahman Al-Rashed
Sheikh Yusuf al-Qaradawi has advised the Egyptian
people to vote yes in the constitutional referendum so
as not to lose out on the US$20 billion in aid
promised by Qatar.
Logically speaking, it is not reasonable for anyone
to vote one way or another on their country's
constitution, which, as described by Dr. Mohammed
ElBaradei, represents the social contract between the
Egyptians and the state, in exchange for financial
support from any third party whatsoever. Al-Qaradawi's
advice is simply another "carrot and stick" ploy, and
such tactics are being used regularly in the run up to
this referendum since the Egyptian President can no
longer impose what he deems appropriate on the people,
as was the case during the reign of Hosni Mubarak. The
ballot box has become the law.
If al-Qaradawi sought to entice the Egyptians with the
gift from Qatar, others went further than that. Mosque
Imams have promised heaven to those who vote ‘yes' and
threatened hellfire to those who vote ‘no'. Meanwhile,
on the other side, there are warnings that voting
‘yes' could plunge Egypt into a crisis and perhaps
even a civil war.
Of course, "billions of dollars", "hellfire" and
"civil war" are all phrases used to stir up and
mobilize the masses. They reflect the importance of
the constitution, as a contract between the regime and
the people, and expectations on all sides are very
high. But what is the value of a constitution that
does safeguard the country? What is the point of a
constitution that divides the Egyptians? More
importantly, who will save Egypt if the constitution
itself is the cause of instability in the country?
It would be impossible for Qatar to pay even one
dollar out of the twenty billion it has promised in
investments and aid, or for the International Monetary
Fund or other donor countries for that matter, if this
conflict continues to shatter Egypt and render it
unstable. Voting ‘yes' or ‘no' will make no difference
if the losers fail to accept the referendum result
with genuine satisfaction and conviction.
The draft constitution and surrounding controversy
have poisoned the political climate. The Egyptian
pound has been dealt a blow in the process and the
widespread discord has caused losses in the stock
market, all of which are worrying signs. No one in
Egypt has the ability to prevent the disaster,
whatever the majority vote, except President Mohammed
Mursi. His task is difficult because each side
considers the referendum to be a decisive issue and
extremists, such as Salafi jihadist groups in Sinai,
have vowed to impose the constitution by force of arms
- although everyone would stand against them if that
happened. The problem is that each side has reached a
degree intolerance and intransigence that leaves no
room for maneuver or retraction later on. Yet
constitutions are supposed to be civil projects, the
details of which can be revised even after the
referendum.
Mursi is the key to the solution. He must demonstrate
genuine leadership through reassuring the anxious
masses and we hope that he will bring together all
parties to his presidential table to fix what the
constitution controversy has ruined. He must surrender
his affiliation and loyalty to the Muslim Brotherhood,
and act as the President of the Republic. Without
being a president of the Copts and the civil forces,
Mursi would remain exclusively as the leader of
Islamist groups; groups that will hound him later on
many issues and demand the impossible.
Mursi must also consider the civilized political
position of opposition leaders. They have all said
that they do not question the legitimacy of his
presidency and do not approve of those seeking to
topple him through a counter revolution. They will
recognize and respect his rights until the end of his
current term. However, it is not certain that the
opposition will continue to uphold such a moral stance
if the president always sides with his own group and
marginalizes other parties.
Al Rashed is the general manager of Al -Arabiya
television. He is also the former editor-in-chief of
Asharq Al- Awsat, and the leading Arabic weekly
magazine, Al Majalla. He is also a senior Columnist in
the daily newspapers of Al Madina and Al Bilad. He is
a US post-graduate degree in mass communications. He
has been a guest on many TV current affairs programs.
He is currently based in Dubai.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments