A Government Without Spies: CIA And Agencies - Inherent Parts Of Any Totalitarian Regime
21 December 2013
By Jacob G. Hornberger
Yesterday, a federal judge ruled
that the NSA's previously super-secret surveillance
scheme over the American people violates the U.S.
Constitution, which sets forth the powers and
restrictions on power that we the people have
established for U.S. officials. Calling the NSA's
surveillance scheme "almost Orwellian," Judge Richard
Leon's ruling is an amazing one, especially given the
long history of the federal judiciary's extreme
deference to the national-security state, especially
when the two magic words—"national security" are
spoken. It is truly incredible that a U.S. District
Judge has actually stepped forward and issued a major
ruling against one of the three principal agencies of
the national-security state. The fact that Leon was
appointed by a Republican, George W. Bush, makes the
ruling even more astounding.
While such a ruling is something that advocates of
liberty and privacy should celebrate, it's important
that Americans go to a higher level. Regardless of how
the courts ultimately rule, as long as the NSA is
permitted to remain in existence it will inevitably
figure out new ways, including illegal ones, to spy on
the American people and monitor their activities in
the name of protecting "national security" and
"keeping us safe." Equally important, as long as the
NSA exists, Americans will have to live their lives
under the assumption that it is spying on them,
recording their telephone calls, and reading their
mail. The only way to avoid that is to abolish, not
rein in, the NSA.
Americans need to be asking themselves some
fundamental questions. Is the NSA — and, indeed, the
entire Cold War-era national-security state apparatus
— compatible with the principles of a free society?
Does the United States really need an NSA? Does
America really need a government that spies on people?
What would life be like in the United States if the
U.S. government wasn't spying on people?
The fact is that the NSA constitutes an extreme
violation of the principles of a free society. Freedom
necessarily entails a zone of privacy, one that is
immune from the prying eyes of government officials.
Freedom entails freely talking on the phone,
corresponding by mail and email, and generally living
one's life without concern that the government is
recording people's calls, reading their mail, and
following them around.
Would America fall into the ocean if the NSA were
abolished? Would it fall victim to a violent takeover
by communists, terrorists, drug dealers, Muslims,
illegal aliens, or boogeymen?
Of course not. But in life under a national-security
state, fear is the coin of the realm.
National-security state officials have to keep people
afraid, constantly afraid. In that way, they can scare
people into supporting whatever they are doing to
infringe upon their freedom and their privacy.
Keep in mind, after all, that the United States lived
without an NSA for almost 200 years. Our American
ancestors would never have tolerated such a
totalitarian edifice to be grafted onto their
constitutional order, which is why Judge Leon stated,
"Surely, such a program infringes on ‘that degree of
privacy' that the founders enshrined in the Fourth
Amendment" and that James Madison would be "aghast" at
what the NSA has been doing.
In fact, it's vitally important that Americans
recognize that the NSA, along with its two sister
agencies in the national-security state apparatus —
the CIA and the military-industrial complex — are
inherent parts of any totalitarian regime. Show me one
totalitarian regime that doesn't inculcate the
citizenry with irrational fears and then spies on the
citizenry in a purported quest to "keep them safe."
The NSA, like the rest of the national-security state,
was brought into existence as a totalitarian method to
fight the Cold War against Soviet totalitarianism,
which, not surprisingly, also had its own
national-security state apparatus. Well, the Cold War
is over. It's time to raise our vision to a higher
level — one that involves more than just reforming or
reining in the NSA. It's time to restore our
fundamental, God-given rights to freedom and privacy.
It's time to abolish the NSA, not reform it.
Jacob G. Hornberger is founder
and president of The Future of Freedom Foundation. He
was born and raised in Laredo, Texas, and received his
B.A. in economics from Virginia Military Institute and
his law degree from the University of Texas. He was a
trial attorney for twelve years in Texas. He also was
an adjunct professor at the University of Dallas,
where he taught law and economics. In 1987, Mr.
Hornberger left the practice of law to become director
of programs at the Foundation for Economic Education.
He has advanced freedom and free markets on talk-radio
stations all across the country as well as on Fox
News' Neil Cavuto and Greta van Susteren shows and he
appeared as a regular commentator on Judge Andrew
Napolitano's show Freedom Watch.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments