Putin Vs. The Black Widows: The Federation's Various Muslim Communities Are Gaining
05 January 2014
By Amir Taheri
As might have been expected, the
latest suicide attacks in Volgograd have brought
Russia back into the headlines just weeks before the
opening of the Winter Olympics in Sochi.
The attacks that claimed at least 60 lives and left
many more injured were carried out by two young women
acting as suicide-bombers. The two attackers are among
an estimated 10,000 young to middle-aged Muslim widows
whose husbands have died in the two decades of war
that Vladimir Putin has waged against insurgents in
parts of the Caucasus.
The Volgograd attacks have received attention because
of the impending show in Sochi. But the deadly
conflict that has already claimed more than 200,000
lives has been going on since Putin scrapped an accord
reached between the Chechen rebels and former
president Boris Yeltsin's emissary Gen. Alexander
Lebed. A war that many had assumed to have been
forgotten has shown that it is anything but that.
Just days before the Volgograd attacks, Haj Makhachev,
the Moscow appointed Deputy Premier of Dagestan, the
mainly Muslim republic whence the two women reportedly
came, was killed in Moscow. In the republic itself
political assassinations have become part of ordinary
life. A similar pattern obtains in the neighboring
republics of Chechnya, Ingushetia and
Charkess-Qarachai.
The women are known as "Black Widows" or Qara-Dulkadin
in the many varieties of Turkish spoken in the
insurgent areas. Their struggle against Putin's Russia
has morphed into a toxic cocktail of ethnic hatred,
tribal vendetta and religious zeal for martyrdom. What
Russia is facing today is the continuation of a
conflict that dates back to the very beginning of
Russians as a distinct people in search of a state of
their own.
In a sense, Russia defined and built its nationhood
with more than two centuries of wars against the
Altaic peoples of the Caucasus, Central Asia and
Siberia. Throughout the nineteenth century the Tsarist
Empire expanded an average rate of 10 square
kilometers (6 miles) each day, at the expense of
Muslim Turkic peoples in a vast region between the
Urals and the Pacific Ocean.
The first crucial step towards Russian nationhood came
when Tsar Ivan the Awe-inspiring, or "Terrible,"
defeated and destroyed the Tatar kingdom based in
Kazan. Not surprisingly, Muslims in general and Turkic
peoples in particular were transmuted into the "other"
and "the enemy" in Russian folklore and literature.
Even Tchaikovsky's famous ballet "Swan Lake" (1876) is
supposed to narrate that conflict.
The choice of Volgograd as the latest arena in what is
a centuries' old conflict is not accidental. The
locality was a Tatar stronghold known as Yellow Water,
in Turkish, Sary-Su, at a strategic point when the
majestic River Volga receives one of its tributaries
known as Tsaritsa. It was and remains the gateway to
the Caucasus. Russians captured the Muslim Tatar city
in the 1580s and developed it as a base for three
centuries of expansion to the south in the hope of
eventually reaching the Indian Ocean through Iran.
The jewel in the crown of Tsarist conquests, the city,
renamed Tsaritsyno, attained an almost mythological
status under its new name: Stalingrad (The City of
Stalin), when it resisted the Nazi invasion and broke
the back of Hitler's war machine in 1943.
Although Putin certainly did not start the current
round of the historic bloody struggle between Russia
and its Muslim communities, his jingoistic approach to
politics is partly responsible for its heating up.
Putin is unable to liberate himself from the Soviet
political culture that shaped him. All he has done is
to replace the old class-based discourse with one
themed on Russia as a Christian nation. In other words
he has based his strategy on the worst aspects of
Tsarist and Stalinist policies vis-à-vis the Muslim
minorities.
However, we have witnessed brief moments in this
checkered history in which Russian Muslims started to
feel as if they were part of a greater reality marked
by diversity. That was the case under Tsar Alexander
I, in the last phase of Tsar Nicholas II's reign, and
after the 20th Congress of the Communist Party of the
Soviet Union (CPSU), in which Nikita Khrushchev
exposed and denounced Stalin's crimes. The blood that
Muslims invested in beating back the Nazi invader made
them feel they had earned their title to first-class
citizenship. President Boris Yeltsin seemed to
understand that, and went a long way to bring Russia's
centuries' old "Muslim problem" closer to a peaceful
solution.
In contrast, Putin has decided to pretend that no such
problem exists. The problems, he tells us, is with
"Muslim terrorists" who are to be "wiped out like
vermin" everywhere, whether in Russia or in Syria. The
reality is less dramatic and more complicated.
Jihadists such as Doku Umarov do maintain a small
support base in Dagestan and Chechnya. But they do not
represent more than a small minority of Russian
citizens.
In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries ethnic
Russians had the upper hand in demographic terms. This
is no longer the case. While ethnic Russians are
losing numbers to the tune of 700,000 a year, the
federation's various Muslim communities are gaining
thanks to higher birth-rates. At the start of the last
century, Muslims accounted for less than four per cent
of the empire's population. Today, they account for 25
per cent in the rump of empire that is the Russian
Federation.
A security officer by training and temperament, Putin
tries to deal with the problem as a police officer.
While the mosquitoes of terror must be crushed, the
real task is to drain the swamps of resentment and
socio-political injustice where they breed. Sadly, the
"Black Widows" are likely to strike again and again.
Amir Taheri was born in Ahvaz, southwest Iran, and
educated in Tehran, London and Paris. He was Executive
Editor-in-Chief of the daily Kayhan in Iran (1972-79).
In 1980-84, he was Middle East Editor for the Sunday
Times. In 1984-92, he served as member of the
Executive Board of the International Press Institute (IPI).
Between 1980 and 2004, he was a contributor to the
International Herald Tribune. He has written for the
Wall Street Journal, the New York Post, the New York
Times, the London Times, the French magazine Politique
Internationale, and the German weekly Focus. Between
1989 and 2005, he was editorial writer for the German
daily Die Welt. Taheri has published 11 books, some of
which have been translated into 20 languages. He has
been a columnist for Asharq Alawsat since 1987.
Taheri's latest book "The Persian Night" is published
by Encounter Books in London and New York.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments