Iraq And The American Cult Of Bombing: Why You Should Expect More Bombs To Be Dropped Everywhere
20 August 2014
By William J. Astore
When you do something again and again, placing great
faith in it, investing enormous amounts of money in
it, only to see indifferent or even negative results,
you wouldn't be entirely surprised if a neutral
observer questioned your sanity or asked you if you
were part of some cult. Yet few Americans question the
sanity or cult-like behaviour of American presidents
as they continue to seek solutions to complex issues
by bombing Iraq (as well as numerous other countries
across the globe).
Poor Iraq. From Operation Desert Shield/Storm under
George H.W. Bush to enforcing no-fly zones under Bill
Clinton to Operation Iraqi Freedom under George W.
Bush to the latest "humanitarian" bombing under Barack
Obama, the one constant is American bombs bursting in
Iraqi desert air. Yet despite this bombing -- or
rather in part because of it -- Iraq is a devastated
and destabilized country, slowly falling apart at
seams that have been unraveling under almost a
quarter-century of steady, at times relentless,
pounding. "Shock and awe," anyone?
Well, I confess to being shocked: that US airpower
assets, including strategic bombers like B-52s and
B-1s, built during the Cold War to deter and, if
necessary, attack that second planetary superpower,
the Soviet Union, have routinely been used to attack
countries that are essentially helpless to defend
themselves from bombing.
In 1985, when I entered active duty as an Air Force
lieutenant, if you had asked me which country the US
would "have" to bomb in four sustained aerial
campaigns spanning three decades, among the last
countries I would have suggested was Iraq. Heck, back
then we were still helping Saddam Hussein in his war
against Iran, sharing intelligence that aided his
military in pinpointing (and using his chemical
weapons against) Iranian troop concentrations. The
Reagan administration had sent future Bush secretary
of defense Donald Rumsfeld there to shake Saddam's
hand for a photo op. We even overlooked Iraq's
"accidental" bombing in 1987 of a American naval
vessel, the USS Stark, that resulted in the death of
37 American sailors, all in the name of containing
Iran (and Shia revolutionary fervor).
It's said that the enemy of my enemy is my friend, but
Saddam didn't remain a friend for long. Emboldened by
US support in his war with Iran, he took Kuwait, only
to initiate the first round of devastating US air
raids against his military during Desert Shield/Storm
in 1990-1991. As these and subsequent bombing
campaigns damaged and debilitated Iraq, contributing
to Saddam's overthrow in 2003, the Shia majority in
that country found common cause with Iran,
strengthening one branch of militant Islam. At the
same time, the general destabilization of Iraq from a
generation of air war and invasion has led to a Sunni
revolt, the strengthening of an al-Qaeda-style
movement, and the establishment of a "caliphate"
across significant parts of Iraq (and Syria).
Now, given that less-than-stellar record, does anyone
want to hazard a guess about the next American
response to peoples and leaders our government doesn't
like in Iraq or the rest of the Middle East? My money
is on more bombing, which surely requires explanation.
Cranking out bombers
If one weapon captured the image of the former Soviet
Union, it was the main battle tank. From T-34s during
World War II to T-72s near the end of the Cold War,
the Russians cranked them out like sausages. And if
one weapon captured the image of the US, then and now,
it has surely been the bomber, whether of the
strategic or heavy variety (think B-52) or the
tactical or fighter-bomber variety (think the F-105 in
the Vietnam years, the F-15 "Strike Eagle" in Iraq,
and for the future, the most expensive weapons system
of all time, the F-35). As the richer superpower, the
US cranked out high-tech bombers like so many
high-priced sausages.
"The bomber will always get through." That article of
faith, first expressed in 1932 by Stanley Baldwin,
thrice Prime Minister of Britain, was seized upon by
US airpower enthusiasts in the run-up to World War II.
Despite decidedly mixed and disappointing results ever
since, bombing remains the go-to choice for American
commanders-in-chief.
What we need in 2014 is a new expression that catches
the essence of the cult of US air power, something
like: "The bomber will always get funded -- and used."
Let's tackle the first half of that equation: the
bomber will always get funded. Skeptical? What else
captures the reality (as well as the folly) of
dedicating more than $400 billion to the F-35
fighter-bomber program, a wildly over-budget and
underperforming weapons system that may, in the end,
cost the American taxpayer $1.5 trillion. Yes, you
read that right. Or the persistence of US plans to
build yet another long-range "strike" bomber to
augment and replace the B-1 and B-2 fleet? It's a
"must-have," according to the Air Force, if the US is
to maintain its "full-spectrum dominance" on Planet
Earth. Already pegged at an estimated price of $550
million per plane while still on the drawing boards,
it's just about guaranteed to replace the F-35 in the
record books, when it comes to delays, cost overruns,
and price. And if you don't think it'll get funded,
you don't know recent history.
Heck, I get it. I was a teenager once. In the 1970s,
as an Air Force enthusiast and child of the Cold War,
I hugged exotic and therefore pricey bomber jets to my
chest. (Well, models of them, anyway.) I considered
them to be both uniquely American and an absolute
necessity when it came to defending our country
against the lumbering (but nevertheless menacing)
Soviet "bear." As a result, I gasped in 1977 when
President Jimmy Carter dared to cancel the B-1 bomber
program. While I was a little young to pen my outrage,
more mature critics than I quickly accused him of
being soft on defense, of pursuing "unilateral
disarmament."
Back then, I'd built a model of the B-1 bomber. In my
mind's eye I still see its sexy white body and its
rakish swing wings. No question that it was a man's
bomber. I recall attaching a firecracker to its body,
lighting the wick, and dropping the plane from the
third-floor porch. It exploded in mid-air, symbolic to
me of the plane's tragic fate at the hands of the
pusillanimous Carter.
But I need not have feared for the B-1. In October
1981, as one of his first major acts in office,
President Ronald Reagan rescinded Carter's
cancellation and revived the mothballed program. The
Air Force eventually bought 100 of the planes for $28
billion, expensive at the time (and called a "turkey"
by some), but a relative bargain in the present
budgetary environment when it comes to bombers (but
these days, little else).
At that point, I was a young lieutenant serving on
active duty in the Air Force. I had by then come to
learn that Carter, the peanut farmer (and former Navy
nuclear engineer), was right. We really didn't need
the B-1 for our defense. In 1986, for a contest at
Peterson Air Force Base where I was stationed, I wrote
a paper against the B-1, terming the idea of a
"penetrating strategic bomber" a "flawed strategy" in
an era of long-range air-launched cruise missiles. It
earned an honorable mention, the equivalent of drawing
the "you have won second prize in a beauty contest"
card in Monopoly, but without the compensatory $10.
That "penetrating," by the way, meant being loaded
with expensive avionics, nowadays augmented by
budget-busting "stealth" features, so that a plane
could theoretically penetrate enemy air defenses while
eluding detection. If the idea of producing such a
bomber was flawed in the 1980s, how much more is it
today, in an age of remotely-piloted drones and
missiles guided by GPS and in a world in which no
country the US chooses to bomb is likely to have air
defenses of any sophistication? Yet the Air Force
insists that it needs at least 100 of the next
generation version of them at a cost of $55 billion.
(Based on experience, especially with the F-35, you
should automatically double or even triple that price
tag, cost overruns and product development delays
being a given in the process. So let's say it'll cost
closer to $150 billion. Check back with me, God
willing, in 2040 to see whether the Air Force's figure
or mine was closer to reality.)
Idols for worship, urges to satisfy
Obviously, there are staggering amounts of money to be
made by feeding America's fetish for bombers. But the
US cult of air power and its wildly expensive
persistence requires further explanation. On one
level, exotic and expensive attack planes like the
F-35 or the future "long range strike bomber" (LRS-B
in bloodless acronym-speak) are the military
equivalent of sacred cows. They are idols to be
worshipped (and funded) without question. But they are
also symptoms of a larger disease -- the engorgement
of the Department of Defense. In the post-9/11 world,
this has become so pronounced that the
military-industrial-congressional complex clearly
believes it is entitled to a trough filled with money
with virtually no accountability to the American
taxpayer.
Add to that sense of entitlement the absurdist faith
of administration after administration in the efficacy
of bombing as a problem solver -- despite overwhelming
evidence to the contrary -- and you have a truly
lethal combo. Senator John McCain was widely mocked by
progressives for his "bomb Iran" song, warbled during
the 2008 presidential campaign to the tune of the
Beach Boys's "Barbara Ann." In fact, his tuneless
rendition captured perfectly Washington's absolute
faith in bombing as a solution to... whatever.
Even if the bombs bursting over Iraq or elsewhere
don't solve anything, even when they make things
worse, they still make a president look, well,
presidential. In America, land of warbirds, it is
always better politically to pose as a hunting hawk
than a helpless dove.
So don't blame the Air Force for wanting more and
deadlier bombers. Or don't blame only them. Just as
admirals want more ships, flyboys naturally want more
planes, even when strategically obsolete from scratch
and blazingly expensive. No military service has ever
willingly given up even a tiny slice of its share of
the prospective budgetary pie, especially if that
slice cuts into the service's core image. In this
sense, the Air Force takes its motto from King Lear's
"Reason not the need!" and from Zack Mayo's "I want to
fly jets!" (memorably uttered by that great
Shakespearean actor Richard Gere in An Officer and a
Gentleman).
The sad truth runs deeper: Americans evidently want
them, too. More bombers. More bombs. In the movie Top
Gun, Tom Cruise's Maverick got it all wrong. It's not
speed Americans feel a need for; they have an urge to
bomb. When you refuse to reason, when you persist in
investing ever more resources in ever more planes, use
almost automatically follows.
In other words, fund it, build it, and, as promised in
the second half of my equation, the bomber will always
get used. Mock him all you want, but John McCain was
on to something. It's bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb bomb if
not (yet) Iran... then Iraq, or Pakistan, or Libya, or
Yemen, or (insert intransigent foreign country/peoples
here).
And like cults everywhere, it's best not to question
the core belief and practices of its leaders -- after
all, bombs bursting in air is now as American as the
"Star Spangled Banner."
-William Astore, a retired lieutenant colonel (USAF),
is a TomDispatch regular who edits the blog The
Contrary Perspective.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments