Israel’s ever-more sadistic reprisals help shore up a sense of victimhood
11 July 2017By Jonathan Cook in
Nazareth
When Israel passed a new counter-terrorism law last year, Ayman Odeh, a leader
of the country’s large minority of Palestinian citizens, described its
draconian measures as colonialism’s “last gasp”. He said: “I see … the panic
of the French at the end of the occupation of Algeria.”
The panic and cruelty plumbed new depths last week, when Israeli officials
launched a $2.3 million lawsuit against the family of Fadi Qanbar, who crashed
a truck into soldiers in Jerusalem in January, killing four. He was shot dead
at the scene.
The suit demands that his widow, Tahani, reimburse the state for the
compensation it awarded the soldiers’ families. If she cannot raise the
astronomic sum, the debt will pass to her four children, the oldest of whom is
currently only seven.
Israel is reported to be preparing many similar cases.
Like other families of Palestinians who commit attacks, the Qanbars are
homeless, after Israel sealed their East Jerusalem home with cement. Twelve
relatives were also stripped of their residency papers as a prelude to
expelling them to the West Bank.
None has done anything wrong – their crime is simply to be related to someone
Israel defines as a “terrorist”.
This trend is intensifying. Israel has demanded that the Palestinian Authority
stop paying a small monthly stipend to families like the Qanbars, whose
breadwinner was killed or jailed. Conviction rates among Palestinians in
Israel’s military legal system stand at more than 99 per cent, and hundreds of
prisoners are incarcerated without charge.
Israeli legislation is set to seize $280 million – a sum equivalent to the
total stipends – from taxes Israel collects on behalf of the Palestinian
Authority, potentially bankrupting it.
On Wednesday Israel loyalists will introduce in the US Senate a bill to
similarly deny the PA aid unless it stops “funding terror”. Issa Karaka, a
Palestinian official, said it would be impossible for the PA to comply:
“Almost every other household … is the family of a prisoner or martyr.”
Israel has taken collective punishment – a serious violation of international
law – to new extremes, stretching the notion to realms once imaginable only in
a dystopian fable like George Orwell’s 1984.
Israel argues that a potential attacker can only be dissuaded by knowing his
loved ones will suffer harsh retribution. Or put another way, Israel is
prepared to use any means to crush the motivation of Palestinians to resist
its brutal, five-decade occupation.
All evidence, however, indicates that when people reach breaking-point, and
are willing to die in the fight against their oppressors, they give little
thought to the consequences for their families. That was the conclusion of an
investigation by the Israeli army more than a decade ago.
In truth, Israel knows its policy is futile. It is not deterring attacks, but
instead engaging in complex displacement activity. Ever-more sadistic forms of
revenge shore up a collective and historic sense of Jewish victimhood while
deflecting Israelis’ attention from the reality that their country is a brutal
colonial settler state.
If that verdict seems harsh, consider a newly published study into the effects
on operators of using drones to carry out extrajudicial executions, in which
civilians are often killed as “collateral damage”.
A US survey found pilots who remotely fly drones soon develop symptoms of
post-traumatic stress from inflicting so much death and destruction. The
Israeli army replicated the study after its pilots operated drones over Gaza
during Israel’s 2014 attack – the ultimate act of collective punishment. Some
500 Palestinian children were killed as the tiny enclave was bombarded for
nearly two months.
Doctors were surprised, however, that the pilots showed no signs of depression
or anxiety. The researchers speculate that Israeli pilots may feel more
justified in their actions, because they are closer to Gaza than US pilots are
to Afghanistan, Iraq or Yemen. They are more confident that they are the ones
under threat, even as they rain down death unseen on Palestinians.
The determination to maintain this exclusive self-image as the victim leads to
outrageous double standards.
Last week the Israeli supreme court backed the refusal by officials to seal up
the homes of three Jews who kidnapped Mohammed Abu Khdeir, a 16-year-old from
Jerusalem, in 2014 and burnt him alive.
In May the Israeli government revealed that it had denied compensation to
six-year-old Ahmed Dawabsheh, the badly scarred, sole survivor of an arson
attack by Jewish extremists that killed his entire family two years ago.
Human rights group B’Tselem recently warned that Israel has given itself
immunity from paying compensation to all Palestinians under occupation killed
or disabled by the Israeli army – even in cases of criminal wrongdoing.
This endless heaping of insult upon injury for Palestinians is possible only
because the west has indulged Israel’s wallowing in victimhood so long. It is
time to prick this bubble of self-delusion and remind Israel that it, not the
Palestinians, is the oppressor.
A version of this article first appeared in the National, Abu Dhabi.
Jonathan Cook won the Martha Gellhorn Special Prize for Journalism. His
latest books are “Israel and the Clash of Civilisations: Iraq, Iran and the
Plan to Remake the Middle East” (Pluto Press) and “Disappearing Palestine:
Israel’s Experiments in Human Despair” (Zed Books). His website is
www.jonathan-cook.net.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments