Islamic State Treatise: Ruling of Shari'a on the Shi'a Sects (Rafidites, Nusayris, Ismailis, Druze)
04 August 2017By Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi
That the Islamic State (IS) detests the Shi'a- both the main body of Shi'a and
the smaller sects and offshoots- is well known. But how exactly does IS
classify those it deems the 'Shi'a sects'? This small treatise, an output from
the Office of Investigations and Studies (part of the Diwan al-'Iftaa' wa al-Buhuth:
Fatwa Issuing and Investigations Department), helps clarify this issue.
This treatise was not in fact published by IS' official media wings online,
but was rather distributed on the ground. For a time, Cole Bunzel and I had
been looking for this work but to no avail. Bunzel recently found it though
and drew my attention to it. I have translated it in full as part of this
post, with occasional explanatory clarifications in square brackets. The
figure who is most likely the "amir" of the office that wrote the introduction
to this treatise is the deceased Bahraini cleric Turki Binali. No official
announcement of his death or eulogy has been published by IS for Binali, and
this absence of an official announcement or eulogy has been taken as a
suggestion that his internal critics now have the ascendancy in IS' main
bodies of authority such as the Delegated Committee, with an apparent document
even calling for the removal of textbooks likely written by him, such as the
Course in Tawheed.
The central argument of this treatise, which going by some of the remarks in
the conclusion appears to have been aimed at clarifying some doubts within the
ranks of some younger members of IS about the status of the Shi'a and related
sects in Islamic law (Shari'a), stipulates that the Shi'a, Alawites, Ismailis
and Druze are not 'original kuffar' (i.e. original disbelievers in Islam like
Jews and Christians), but are rather apostates: that is, people who have
abandoned Islam. Note that the treatise makes an exception for Druze who do
not claim to be Muslims, as many of them do not identify themselves as a sect
of Islam, while others among them do. If there is no claimed affiliation with
Islam, one cannot be an apostate.
The stipulation of apostasy for the Shi'a and related/derived sects goes
against an arguably intuitive stream of thought that might posit that with the
passing of generations from the time of their ancestors' original apostasy
from Islam, today's Shi'a are simply original disbelievers like the Jews and
Christians, since they were not born into Islam. The conception of Shi'a as
apostates is notably consistent with the line in the 'Islam 101' pamphlet
issued by IS and published online by its 'al-Himma Library', called 'This is
our 'Aqeeda and This is our Manhaj', which explicitly classifies the Shi'a as
an apostate sect among the Muslims.
Since apostasy is regarded as worse than original kufr (disbelief), then
fighting apostasy and its adherents in their various forms is accorded
priority. An illustration of this line of thinking comes in an extended
quotation in this treatise from Abu Mus'ab al-Zarqawi's speech "Have you heard
of the Rafidites?" Zarqawi, speaking during the time of the U.S. occupation of
Iraq, invoked a supposed precedent from the time of the Crusades to justify
the idea of waging war on the Shi'a. Just as Salah al-Din did not retake
Jerusalem from the Crusaders until after the end of the Shi'i Fatimid dynasty
in Egypt, so today's jihadists will not defeat the Crusaders of this era until
they destroy the Shi'a first. Zarqawi's view of history is simplistic, to say
the least, but the reasoning is clear.
As far as the citations and influences go, the Wahhabi concept of 'nullifiers'
of Islam unsurprisingly comes up, a key foundation on which IS conceptions of
falling into kufr and apostasy are based. Both the founder of the Wahhabi
trend and subsequent scholars like Suleiman bin Sahman are cited in this work.
The medieval Hanbali scholar Ibn Taymiyya, known for his virulently anti-Alawite
views in particular, also features in this treatise on multiple occasions,
just as he features in other IS theology books. At the same time, however, one
of the main points this treatise invokes to support its central argument that
the Shi'a are apostates is that the view of Shi'a as apostates was held by the
traditional Sunni jurists and theologians, whereas the view of them as
original disbelievers is an innovation deviating from tradition. Some sayings
on the Shi'a quoted in this work are traced back to some of the early imams
and hadith narrators in Sunni Islam, like Muhammad bin Yusuf al-Faryabi and
Talha bin Masraf. These sayings were quoted in later Sunni theology works such
as Sharh Usul 'Itiqad Ahl al-Sunna wa al-Jama'at ("Explaining the principles
of the doctrine of the Ahl al-Sunna wa al-Jama'at: a work by Imam al-Lalika'i)
and al-Ibana al-Sughra (a work by Ibn Batta, a Hanbali jurist of the 10th
century CE). The renowned Persian theologian al-Ghazali, a Shafi'i, is also
quoted in this work with regards to his views on adherents of 'Batini'
thought, in particular referring to the Ismailis. Ibn 'Abidin, a Syrian jurist
of the Hanafi school of jurisprudence, is cited with regards to the Druze in
particular. It should be noted though that this treatise gives a somewhat
misleading picture of Ibn 'Abidin's view of the Druze. While he did consider
them outside of the fold of Islam, he also wrote in the same work quoted by
this treatise: "It is not hidden that their [Druze et al.] establishment on
the two Shahadas with this evil doctrine does not place them in the ruling of
the apostate for lack of credence."
The IS notion of not deviating from tradition also explains the attempt to
give an overview where necessary of differing views of the four main schools
of Sunni jurisprudence (Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali and Hanafi), as part of the
background on the general concept of apostasy and the subject of definitions.
This approach again illustrates that one cannot claim that IS rejects the four
schools of jurisprudence.
Islamic State
Office of Investigations and Studies
Ruling of Shari'a on the Shi'a sects
(Rafidites, Nusayris, Ismailis, Druze).
Office of Investigations and Studies
First printing
In the name of God, the Compassionate, the Merciful
Introduction of the amir of the office of investigations and studies
Praise be to God who makes mighty the one who obeys Him and lowers the one who
rebels against Him, and prayers and peace be upon His Messenger and Mustafa,
and on his family, companions and whoso is close to him. As for what follows:
The sects of the Shi'a are numerous, and all of them are sects that claim
affiliation with Islam, and claim loyalty to Ali bin Abi Talib (may God be
pleased with him), therefore they are called Shi'a.
Imam Ibn Batta al-'Ukbar- may God have mercy on him- said about the Shi'a:
"The people strongest in disagreement, divergence and attacking each other,
for each one chooses a madhhab for himself and curses the one who disagrees
with him on it, and declares takfir on the one who does not follow it" (al-Ibana
al-Kubra: 2/556).
And of these sects, some are worse than others, and the most well-known and
worst of those sects:
1. The Twelver Imamate, Ja'afari Rafidite Shi'a, called the Imamate because
they have made the Imamate the foundational cause that drives them, and they
are called Twelver because they have said that there were twelve Imams, the
last of whom entered the cave in Samarra according to their claim. They are
called Ja'afaris in derivation from Imam Ja'afar al-Sadiq (may God have mercy
on him), and they are called Rafidites because they rejected the Imamate of
the two sheikhs and then rejected Islam.
2. The Alawite Nusayri Shi'a and they are a Batini sect that appeared in the
third century of the Hijra, and they are called Nusayris in relation to the
founder of the sect Muhammad bin Nusayr al-Basri al-Numayri (died in 270 AH),
and they called Alawis in relation to Ali bin Abi Talib (may God be pleased
with him).
3. The Ismaili Shi'a and they are a Batini sect, called Ismailis in relation
to Ismail bin Ja'afar al-Sadiq.
4. The Druze Shi'a and they are a Batini sect that deifies the Caliph al-Obeidi
al-Hakim bi-Amr Allah, having adopted most of its doctrines from the Ismailis,
and they are called Druze in relation to Nashtakin al-Darazi.[i]
And all these sects commit great nullifiers from the nullifiers of Islam, like
deifying humans, professing the doctrine of hulul [divine incarnation],
condemning the concept of the Resurrection, transmigration of souls, calling
for help in one besides God, declaring takfir on the mass of the companions,
attacking the honour of the Mother of the Believers A'isha (may God be pleased
with her), and professing that the Qur'an has been distorted, and other things
from plain acts of kufr in the books of these sects.
And Imam al-Sha'abi- may God have mercy on him- spoke the truth when he said
about them: "Had the Shi'a been from among the birds, they would have been
vultures, and had they been from the riding animals, they would have been
donkeys"- (brought out by al-Lalka'i in Sharh al-Sunna 7/1267).
A doctrine of kufr, error, and strife, a doctrine of rejecting Islam and the
Sunnas. The religion of the Rafidites strives in its establishment among men
for the worship of the grave and idols.
And for the repulsiveness of what they have said, and the ugliness of what
they have done, many of the contemporaries have thought that these sects are
original kuffar, but the matter is not what they have thought, but rather they
are apostate sects.
In order for their state of affairs to be become utterly clear, and for the
present confusion to be removed, we have written these lines that we have
called: "The ruling of Shari'a on the Shi'a sects."[ii]
And the last of our calls is praise be to God the Lord of the Worlds, and
God's blessings and peace be upon the most noble of the prophets and those
sent.
Section: Defining apostasy as a word and technical term
The precepts from the Book of God and the Sunna of the Messenger of God (God's
peace and blessings be upon him and his family) have brought mention of
apostasy and committing apostasy.
Apostasy is taken from 'going back' in the Arabs' language, and therefore the
'ulama- may God have mercy on them- agreed that apostasy in the language is
'going back', so all the sources of the language agree that the notion of
apostasy goes back to the notion of going back on something.
As a technical term: the definitions of the 'ulama- may God have mercy on
them- have differed on the truth of apostasy and the apostate, for some of the
'ulama say that apostasy is going back from the faith as some of the Hanafi
jurists- may God have mercy on them- define it.
Imam Abu Bakr al-Kasani al-Hanafi- may God have mercy on him- said: "As for
the principle of apostasy, it is carrying out the word of kufr on the tongue
after the presence of faith, so apostasy is an expression of going back on
faith" (Bada'i al-Sana'i- 7/134).
And some say: the kufr of the Muslim, as a group of the 'ulama have defined
it, among them the Maliki jurists.
Abu al-Abbas al-Sawi al-Maliki- may God have mercy on him- said: "Apostasy is
the kufr of the Muslim in an open sense of declaration, or words that
necessitate kufr, or doing something that includes kufr"- (al-Sharh al-Saghir-
6/144).
And some of them say: cutting off Islam, as the Shafi'i jurists define it.
Shams al-Din al-Sharbini al-Shafi'i- may God have mercy on him- said:
"Apostasy is cutting off Islam intentionally, equally whether doing or saying
something in mockery, or out of pigheadedness, or creed"- (Mughni al-Muhtaj-
4/133).
And some say: going back on Islam, as the Hanbali jurists define it.
Imam Ibn Qudama al-Hanbali- may God have mercy on him- said: "The apostate is
the one who returns from the religion of Islam to kufr"- (al-Mughni 9/3).
Those of the four madhahib are agreed in the meaning of apostasy even if their
expressions differ, for all of the have defined it as going back on Islam, and
this is the evidence of the Qur'an. God Almighty said: "And they will continue
fighting you till they make you turn away from your religion if they can, and
whoso among you apostasises from his religion is a kafir, and the deeds of
those people have come to naught in this world and the Hereafter, and those
people are companions of the fire, in which they will abide forever"- al-Baqara
217 [Qur'an 2:217].
And God Almighty said: "Oh you who believe, whoso among you apostasises from
his religion, God will bring a people whom He loves, and they love him, humble
to the believers and powerful against the disbelievers, striving in the path
of God, and they do not fear the censure of a critic. This is God's grace that
He bestows on whoso He wishes. God is all-Encompassing, all-Knowing"- al-Ma'ida
54 [Qur'an 5:54].
Section: Islam in the Legal Sense and the True Islam
The one who bears the bond of Islam- there is no deity but God- or claims
affiliation with Islam or shows something from its outward rituals, the ruling
for him is Islam, and upon him has come the rulings of Islam in this world,
and this is known as "Islam in the Legal Sense."
And if he is outwardly and inwardly a believer, and bears the conditions of
there is no deity but God, and avoids its nullifiers etc., he is a Muslim in
truth, and for him are the rulings of Islam in this world and the Hereafter,
and this is known as "True Islam."
As for the one who should commit one of the nullifiers of Islam we have not
reviewed, or if he has not fulfilled some of the conditions of there is no
deity but God, or if he outwardly shows Islam and inwardly bears kufr, for him
is "Islam in the Legal Sense" only, and not true Islam.
The Sheikh of Islam Ibn Taymiyya (may God have mercy on him) said: "And in
this they have replied concerning this proof, for when it is said to them that
the Muslims have agreed that the kafir wants to become Muslim, it suffices
from him to affirm the two shahadas. They say: 'Indeed we are content with him
in that to carry out Islam upon him.' For the One of the Law [God] made it a
sign for implementing the rulings.
But if that were true faith He would not have said regarding the muhajir
women: 'Oh you who believe, if believing muhajir women come to you, examine
them. God is all-Knowing of their faith'- (Dir' Ta'arudh al-Aql wa al-Naql-
7/437).
Imam Ibn Abi al-Izz al-Hanafi- may God have mercy on him- said: "And there are
issues on which the jurists speak, like the one who prays and does not profess
the two shahadas, or bears something besides that from the particulars of
Islam but does not profess them. Is he a Muslim or not? And the truth is that
he is a Muslim in all that is from the particulars of Islam" (Sharh al-Tahawia-
75).
Therefore know that anyone who professes affiliation with Islam and bears
something that nullifies it is an apostate, so the sects that claim
affiliation with Islam like the Shi'a sects are apostates, not original kuffar.
And we have not come to know a transmission from one of the predecessor imams
that designated the one who has claimed affiliation with Islam and has fallen
into disbelief an original kafir.
Section: True Apostasy and Apostasy in the Legal Sense
It must be known that the one who embraces Islam outwardly and inwardly but
then commits one of its nullifiers is an apostate in the true sense, because
he has cut off Islam or gone back on it. As for the one who bears Islam
outwardly then nullifies it, or professes affiliation with Islam then resolves
upon himself that he was not Muslim at all, he is an apostate in the legal
sense rather than the true sense, as he is in his true nature an original
kafir.
The 'alama Suleiman al-Bajirmi al-Shafi'i (died in 1221 AH) said: "And this is
the definition of true apostasy, as for the son of the apostate who was bound
into apostasy, he is an apostate in the legal sense because Islam was not cut
off from him...Likewise the atheist, even if he cut off Islam outwardly, is
not called an apostate in the true sense because there was no Islam in him to
cut off, so his apostasy is in the legal sense" (Hashiyat al-Bajirmi 'Ala al-Khatib-
4/237).
Therefore it is known that the Shi'a sects are apostates in the legal sense,
even if they have not fulfilled the conditions of the shahada from the outset.
Section: Kufr in the True and Legal Sense
One must distinguish between true kufr and kufr in the legal sense, just as a
distinction is made between true Islam and Islam in the legal sense, as well
as there being a distinction between true apostasy and apostasy in the legal
sense. Likewise here.
For the Imams stipulated that all who show kufr have the rulings of kufr upon
them, and is judged in kufr, but he may be excused in one of the impediments
to takfir we have not come to know.
So we judge the children of the disbelievers with kufr in the legal sense
following their parents, even as the text has established that they are born
in fitra- i.e. Islam- on the authority of Abu Huraira, who said: "The
Messenger of God (SAWS) said: 'It is not that the one who is born should be
born except in fitra, so it is the child's parents that make him a Jew,
Christian and Majusi, just as the animal delivers a whole animal. Do you
perceive it as mutilated?' Then Abu Huraira said: 'Recite if you will- 'The
fitra of God on which He has created the people, there is no replacement for
God's creation'- the aya' [Qur'an 30:30]"- (agreed upon).
The Sheikh of Islam Ibn Taymiyya (may God have mercy on him) said: "And there
is that which clarifies the Almighty's words in the other hadith: Every child
is born on fitra until his tongue can utter it, whether thankful or
ungrateful.
So He has put the child on fitra until he can comprehend and can make
distinctions, when one of the two matters can be established for him, and if
he inwardly disbelieves in the kufr of his parents, that would be from the
time of birth, before his tongue could utter it. Likewise the Almighty's words
in the other authentic hadith of Ayad bin Hamar, from the Prophet (SAWS) in
talking about his Lord: 'I created My servants as hunafa' [monotheists], so
the Shayateen [evil ones] have caused them to deviate and have forbidden upon
them what I allowed for them, and ordered them to associate as partners with
Me what I did not bring down as authority.'
It is clear they [men] have been created in the hanif state, and the Shayateen
have caused them to deviate, forbidden upon them what is permitted, and
ordered them to commit shirk, so if the child were to become a disbeliever in
the same state from the time of his birth, for the fact that he follows his
parents in the religion before someone teaches him disbelief and instils him
with it, the Shayateen were not the ones who deviated them from the Hanif
state and ordered them to commit shirk, but rather they were mushrikeen from
the time of their birth following their parents.
And the source of misgiving in this issue is the fact that the rulings of kufr
in this world are confused with the rulings of kufr in the Hereafter, for the
children of the kuffar, since they have been dealt with by the rulings of kufr
in the matters of this world, like the establishment of guardianship upon them
for their parents, and their parents' nurturing for them, and the fact that
their parents can teach them and educate them, and inheritance between them
and their parents, and their enslavement if their parents were among those
waging war, and things besides that- thus has come about the opinion of the
one who thinks that they are kuffar in the same state, as the one who
professes kufr and acts on it"- (Dir' Ta'arudh al-Aql wa al-Naql- 8/432).
Section: General Islam and Particular Islam
One may use the term Islam in the law with the general meaning, which is Islam
facing towards God, obeying Him, worshipping Him alone, disavowing shirk,
belief in the prophets, the principle, the resurrection etc. And this is the
religion of all the prophets.
The Sheikh of Islam Ibn Taymiyya (may God have mercy on him) said: "All the
Prophets were sent with the religion of Islam for it is the religion besides
which God does not accept, not from the first nor from the last"- ('al-Abudiya
115-6).
And the term Islam may be used in the particular sense: the religion with
which Muhammad (SAWS and on his family) was sent in doctrine, Shari'a and
ethics.
Imam al-Baghawi (may God have mercy on him) said: "The religion of Islam is
following the Qur'an"- (Tafsir al-Baghawi- 1/13).
Imam al-Barbahari (may God have mercy on him) said: "Know that Islam is the
Sunna"- (Sharh al-Sunna: 133).
God Almighty said: "And I have been ordered to be the first of the Muslims."
Al-Siddi said: "Meaning from the Ummah of SAWS" (see: Tafsir Ibn Kathir 6/83).
And Imam al-Shawkani (may God have mercy on him) said: "i.e. From this Ummah"
(Fath al-Qadir 3/454).
Thus, know that the kuffar who were before the sending of the seal of the
Prophets (SAWS and on his family) are original kuffar. It is not said that
they are apostates, and we are not bound to that on the grounds that their
origin is the Islam as they are from the offspring of Adam and Noah- peace be
upon them- as Imam al-Kasani- may God have mercy on him- formulated in his
discussion of the descendants of the apostates (see Bada'i al-Sana'i 7/139).
So apostasy in the technical term of the 'ulama is rather applied to the one
who leaves Islam in the particular sense, not the general sense.
Section: Ruling on the children of the apostates
There has not come a clear stipulation from the Book and Sunna regarding the
ruling on the children of the apostates, therefore the Imams have differed in
their pronouncements.
Perhaps their pronouncements in distinguishing the apostasy of the parents
come in three types:
1. The fact that the parents apostasise in their committing one of the
nullifiers of Islam concerns them, like blasphemy against God Almighty or
supporting the kuffar over the Muslims, and the like, so their children are
Muslims in principle if they claim affiliation with Islam, and the predominant
opinion is that their children are established on Islam.
On the authority of Abu Huraira (may God be pleased with him): he said: "the
Prophet (SAWS) said: 'It is not that the one who is born should be born except
in fitra, so it is the child's parents that make him a Jew, Christian and
Majusi, just as the animal bears an animal whole. Do you perceive it as
mutilated?' Then Abu Huraira (may God be pleased with him) said: 'The fitra of
God on which He has created the people,'" (agreed upon).
So Imam al-Nawawi (may God have mercy on him) said regarding the one whose
parents have become apostates: "As for the apostate's son, if he is separated,
or bound before the apostasy, he is a Muslim; even if a pregnant mother
apostasises, the child is not judged in apostasy, but if he comes of age and
expresses kufr, he is an apostate himself"- (Rawdhat al-Talibeen: 10/77).
And what he said in that is for the most likely thought.
2. That the parents who apostasise by their committing one of the nullifiers
of Islam with the adoption of it as a madhhab and path, so their children are
apostates, for it is most likely that the children are raised on that.
Imam al-Qarafi (may God have mercy on him) said: "Malik said: All born to an
apostate after his apostasy has the ruling of the apostate"- (al-Dhakira
12/42).
Imam al-Kasani (may God have mercy on him) said on the children of the
apostates: "If he is born in apostasy by the fact that the spouses apostasised
when they didn't have a child, and then the wife became pregnant from her
husband after her apostasy, and the two are apostates in their state, so this
child in the care of his parents has for him the ruling of apostasy, even if
he dies, he is not to be prayed for, because the apostate is not the heir of
anyone" (Bada'i al-Sana'i- 7/139). But he disagreed on descendants!
3. That the parents apostasise by their conversion to a new religion like
Judaism or Christianity, so their children are original kuffar.
Imam al-Zarkashi (may God have mercy on him) said: "And the understanding of
al-Kharqi's words is that their children who were born after the apostasy,
even if they refrain from Islam, are not automatically to be killed, but in
this regard are two conceptions. (One of the two) is that they have chosen
kufr in which its people are not established with jizya, so here there is no
doubt in killing them. (The second) is that they have chosen kufr in which its
people are established with jizya, and here are two reports: one is reported
by Abu al-Barakat, and Abu Muhammad in al-Muqni', and it is the literal
meaning of al-Kharqi's words, and the judge's choice in his two reports: they
are established in jizya, because they were born among kafirs, and the ruling
of Islam did not apply to them previously, so he allowed for them to be
established in jizya as the children of those at war..." (Sharh al-Zarkashi on
the Mukhtasir al-Kharqi 6/258).
This distinction makes clear and clarifies that the imams who judged that the
children of apostates are original kuffar did not rule on the Shi'a sects that
they adhere to original kufr as a result of successive birth and succession on
kufr with the passing of eras.
Section: Truth of the apostasy of the Shi'a sects
The Shi'a sects claim affiliation with Islam, profess that there is no deity
but God, establish prayer, give zakat, fast in Ramadan and perform the Hajj.
But they commit numerous nullifiers of Islam that are from their principles,
and man will not be one of them except when he professes them.
So they are apostates in ruling even if it is said that they have not believed
at all, for in al-Bukhari from Ikrima, who said: "Some heretics were brought
to Ali- may God be pleased with him- so he burnt them, so that reached Ibn
Abbas, who said: 'Had I been in his place, I would not have burnt them, for
the Messenger of God (SAWS) forbade it- 'Do not punish with the punishment of
God.' I would have killed them per the words of the Messenger of God (SAWS):
'Whoso changes his religion, kill him.'"
And in al-Nisa'i from Anas: that Ali was brought people of al-Zutt who were
worshipping idols, so he burnt them, and the news reached Ibn Abbas, who said:
'Indeed the Messenger of God (SAWS) said: 'Whoso changes his religion, kill
him.'"
And in Abu Ya'ala from Anas: that Ali was brought people of al-Zutt whom they
found worshipping idols, so he burnt them, and the news reached Ibn Abbas, who
said: 'Indeed the Messenger of God (SAWS) said: 'Whoso changes his religion,
kill him.'"
So despite the fact that the predecessors found among these people idols being
worshipped, and ruled on them as heretics, they brought on them the rulings of
the apostates, not original kuffar, as they claimed affiliation with Islam.
Imam al-Bukhari- may God have mercy on him- said in his authentic collection:
"...So Abu Bakr said: By God I should certainly fight the one who has caused
separation between what the Messenger of God (SAWS) brought together, then
later Omar followed him and Abu Bakr did not consider consultation as there
was with him the ruling of the Messenger of God (SAWS) on those who caused
separation between prayer and zakat and wanted to change the religion and its
rulings, and the Prophet (SAWS) said: 'Whoso changes his religion, kill him.'"
Thus, these sects are sects of apostasy, exchanging many of the principles of
Islam and its designs. And those affiliated with them are apostates, children
of apostates, as presented.
Section: some of the sayings of the 'ulama on the ruling on the Rafidites
The 'ulama- may God have mercy on them- spoke about the Rafidites, and made
clear the ruling on them and clarified their status.
Imam Talha bin Masraf (may God have mercy on him) said: "The women of the
Rafidites are not to be married and the meat of the animals they slaughter not
to be eaten, because they are a people of apostasy" (al-Ibana al-Sughra 161).
And from Imam Ahmad bin Yunis (may God have mercy on him) who said: "We do not
eat the meat of the animal slaughtered by a Rafidite man, as he is in my eyes
an apostate" (Sharh Usul 'Itiqad Ahl al-Sunna wa al-Jama'at, al-Lalika'i
8/1546).
And transmitted from him by the Sheikh of Islam Ibn Taymiyya (may God have
mercy on him) in al-Sarim al-Maslul 570, who said: "Were a Jew to slaughter
sheep, and were a Rafidite to do it, I would eat the meat of the Jew, and I
have not eaten the meat of the Rafidite because he is an apostate from Islam."
Imam Abd al-Rahman bin Mahdi (may God have mercy on him) said: "I have not
looked into a Rafidite and did not find him to be a heretic" (Sharh Usul 'Itiqad
Ahl al-Sunna wa al-Jama'at 7/1343).
Imam Muhammad bin Yusuf al-Faryabi (may God have mercy on him) said: "I only
see the Rafidites and Jahmis as heretics" (Sharh Usul 'Itiqad Ahl al-Sunna wa
al-Jama'at 8/1545).
The Sheikh of Islam Ibn Taymiyya (may God have mercy on him) said: "And there
may be apostasy from some of the religion, as is the state of the people of
Rafidite innovations and others besides them, and God Almighty will establish
a people He loves and they love Him, and will wage jihad against the one who
apostasises from the religion or some of it, as He will establish the one who
wages jihad against the Rafidite apostates from the religion, or from some of
it, in every age. And God- Exalted is He- is the One responsible for making us
among those he Loves and they love Him, who will wage jihad on the apostates
and the followers of the apostates, and they do not fear the censure of the
critic" (Manhaj al-Sunna 7/222).
Abu Hamid al-Maqdisi (may God have mercy on him) said after he mentioned most
of the doctrines of the Rafidites: "It is not hidden to anyone of insight and
understanding from the Muslims, that most of what we have presented in the
chapter previously regarding the doctrines of this Rafidite sect despite the
difference of their types is plain kufr, and pigheadedness with ugly
ignorance. The one familiar does not stop with takfir of them, and the ruling
on them in deviating from the religion of Islam and their error"- (Risala fi
al-Radd 'Ala al-Rafida li-Abi Hamid al-Maqdisi 200).
The revivalist Sheikh Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab (may God have mercy on him)
said: "These Imamates go outside the Sunna, but also the path [/faith of
Islam]" (Risala fi al-Radd 'Ala al-Rafida li-Sheikh Muhammad 39).
And Sheikh Suleiman bin Sahman- may God have mercy on him- said: "It is known
that the Imamate Rafidites among all the Ahl al-Sunna wa al-Jama'at are not
from the people of the Islamic path and way of Muhammad, but rather they are
outside of them entirely" (al-Hujjaj al-Wadhiha al-Islamiya 77).
Section: Some of the words of the 'ulama on the ruling on the Nusayris,
Ismailis and Druze
The words of the Imams- may God have mercy on them- on the apostasy of the
Nusayris, Ismailis and Druze who claim affiliation with Islam is clearer than
their words on the apostasy of the Rafidites.
Imam Abu Hamid al-Ghazali- may God have mercy on him- said: "And the summary
pronouncement is that there passes in them- that is, the Batiniya- the way of
the apostates in view, blood, wealth, marriage, meat of the animals they
slaughter, the authority of judgements and the extirpation of the acts of
worship. As for their lives, the way of the original kafir does not go through
them as a distinction is made in the kafir between four characteristics-
bestowal, ransom, enslavement and killing- and the distinction is not made
with regards to the apostate...and it is obligatory to kill them and cleanse
the face of the earth from them"- (Fada'ih al-Batiniya 156).
And the Sheikh of Islam Ibn Taymiyya (may God have mercy on him) said: "These
Druze and Nusayris are kuffar by the agreement of the Muslims: it is not
allowed to eat the meat of the animals they slaughter or marry their women, or
even for them to be established on jizya, for they are apostates from the
religion of Islam, not Muslims, Jews or Christians. They do not establish the
obligation of he give prayers or the obligation of fasting in Ramadan or the
obligation of the Hajj, or forbid what God and His Messenger forbade from
forbidden meat, wine and other things, even if they outwardly the two shahadas
with these doctrines, they are kuffar by agreement of the Muslims" (Majmu' al-Fatawa
35/161).
The 'Alama ibn Abidin- may God have mercy on him- said: "Concerning the ruling
of the Druze and the Tayamina, the Nusayris and Ismailis [note]. It is known
from what is here the ruling of the Druze and Tayamina, for they are in the
land of the Levant showing Islam outwardly with fasting and prayer despite the
fact that they believe in the transmigration of souls...[cont.]
the permissibility of wine and fornication, and that divinity appears in
person after person, and they disavow the congregation, fasting, prayer and
Hajj, and they say the attribute in name as something besides the desired
meaning, and they speak hideous words about our honoured Prophet (SAWS). And
the 'alama Abd al-Rahman al-Amadi verifying their case has an elaborate fatwa,
in which he mentioned that they plagiarise the doctrines of the Nusayris and
Ismailis who are called by the names of Qarmatians and Batinis whom the one of
positions mentioned. And he transmitted from the 'ulama of the four madhahib
that it is not allowed for them to be established in the abode of Islam with
jizya or anything besides that, and it is not allowed to marry them or eat the
meat of the animals they slaughter, and against them is a fatwa in benevolence
as well so consult. Concerning the clause 'the one whose repentance should not
be accepted,' in short the attribute of heretic, hypocrite and deviant applies
to them..." (Radd al-Muhtar 'Ala al-Dir al-Mukhtar 4/244).
Sheikh Abd al-Rahman bin Hassan bin Muhammad bin Abd al-Wahhab (may God have
mercy on him) said: "And the first about whom the claim to prophethood
appeared from those who claim affiliation to Islam: al-Mukhtar bin Abi Obeid,
and he was from the Shi'a, so it has been known that the greatest people in
apostasy are among the Shi'a, more than those in the other sects, and in this
regard no worse apostasy is known than the apostasy of the ghulat, like the
Nusayris, and the apostasy of the Batini Ismailis, and others besides them.
Period. And it is known that many of these people are ignorant thinking they
are on the way of truth, and despite that the Sheikh of Islam [Ibn Taymiyya]
ruled on the evil of their apostasy" (al-Dorar al-Sunniya 11/482).
Section: the Islamic State's Adoption of the pronouncement of the apostasy
of the Shi'a sects
The Islamic State has adopted what the Imams of Islam of old and modern times
adopted in the ruling on the Shi'a sects, and has not departed from their
sayings with a new pronouncement.
For its sheikhs, founders, and Shari'i elements noted the apostasy of the
Rafidites.
For Sheikh Abu Mus'ab al-Zarqawi (may God have mercy on him) made that clear
in his series entitled 'Have you heard of the Rafidites?' And from what he
said about them after he elaborated their doctrine: "The Muslims cannot be
victorious or overcome the kuffar who wage war from the Jews and Christians
except after annihilating those besides them from the apostate collaborators,
at the head of whom are the Rafidites, just as history has observed for us how
Bayt al-Maqdis [Jerusalem] that fell at the hands of Crusaders with the help
of the Obeidi Rafidites was not recovered except at the hands of 'Salah
al-Din,' even as 'Nur al-Din Mahmoud' was stronger against the Crusaders than
'Salah al-Din', but God Almighty determined that the victory and liberation of
Bayt al-Maqdis should be at the hands of 'Salah al-Din', but when? After he
waged war on the Obeidi Rafidites for a number of years, and totally destroyed
their state and brought it down, then after that he was freed up to take on
the Crusaders until the victory over them came about for him, and he recovered
Bayt al-Maqdis that remained for years under their grip because of the
Rafidite people of betrayal. So this is a very important lesson that history
offers us that can never be ignored.
Victory will never arise for us over the original kuffar except after fighting
the apostate kuffar with the original kuffar, and the Islamic conquests that
were fulfilled in the era of the Rashideen were not so except after cleansing
the Arabian Peninsula of the apostates, and therefore the one the Rafidites
detest most is 'Salah al-Din,' for they tolerate death but do not tolerate
him."
And similarly the Amir al-Mu'mineen Abu Omar al-Baghdadi (may God have mercy
on him) as he said in clarifying the creed of the Islamic State: "Secondly:
The Rafidites are a sect of shirk and apostasy, and they are with that
refusing to apply many of the outward rituals of Islam"- (recording: Qul
Innani 'Ala Bayyinatin min Rabbi).
And he said in the recording of "Religion is advice": "So the alliance with
the Nusayri Rafidites in Syria on the grounds of liberating Palestine is a
very great betrayal, for indeed Salah al-Din did not enter al-Quds in conquest
except after destroying the Obeidi Rafidite state in Egypt and al-Sham, and
the Nusayris are the most evil in creed and greatest in hatred. The Sheikh of
Islam Ibn Taymiyya (may God have mercy on him) said: 'And the Nusayris are
kuffar by the agreement of the Muslims, it is not allowed to eat the meat of
the animals they slaughter, marry their women, and they are also not
established on jizya, for they are apostates from the religion of Islam and
they are not Muslims, Jews or Christians' (Majmu'at al-Fatawa 35-161).
And likewise the Amir al-Mu'mineen Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi- may God protect him
and strengthen him- when he spoke in the recording 'And even if the kafirs
hate': "Be strong against the Houthi Rafidites, for they are apostate kuffar."
Section: The weakness of pronouncing the Shi'a sects to be original kuffar
Pronouncing the Shi'a sects to be original kuffar is implausible in multiple
ways, among them:
1. Pronouncing the Shi'a sects to be original kuffar is a modern innovation:
The works of the foundations of the Ahl al-'Ilm and their bases require that
one must not be isolated from their jurisprudence and deductions, for these
sects have been present since the first centuries of the history of Islam, and
we have not come to know any considered trace for one of the Imams of Islam
stipulating that they are original kuffar.
For the pronouncement that these sects are original kuffar came after the 'ulama
who passed, the jurists who judged, and the most beautiful expression is what
has been narrated from the Imam of the Ahl al-Sunna Ahmad bin Hanbal- may God
have mercy on him- that he said: "Do not say something for which you have no
Imam."
And Abu Hafs al-Haddad was asked about innovation, and said: "Attacking the
rulings, and disregarding the Sunnas, following opinions and whims, and
abandoning following and emulation" (al-'Itisam lil-Shatibi 1/162).
2. Saying that the Shi'a sects are original kuffar contravenes the consensus.
The first centuries of Islam's history passed and not one 'alim ruled that
these sects are original kuffar, but rather many of them- without disagreement
we know of- ruled that they are apostate kuffar.
So the outcome of saying that they are original kuffar is a contravention of
the Ummah's consensus. God Almighty said: "Whoever opposes the Messenger after
the guidance is made clear to him, and follows a path besides that of the
believers, We will grant him what he has assumed and drive him to hellfire.
And evil it is as a destination" (Nisa' 115) [Qur'an 4:115].
And there has come in the mutawatar [multiple chains of transmission] hadith
from SAWS that he said: "A sect of my Ummah will remain open on the truth, and
the one who forsakes them will not harm them until the decree of God should
come, and they are so" (brought out by Muslim).
Imam al-Nawawi (may God have mercy on him) said in explaining the hadith: "In
it is evidence that consensus is a proof, and it is the surest thing to be
inferred from the hadith, and as for hadith- 'My Ummah does not gather on
error', it is weak"- (Sharh Sahih Muslim 13/67).
3. Some of the inferences of saying that the Shi'a sects are original kuffar:
Saying that the Shi'a sects are original kuffar has many false inferences,
among them:
1. The lack of compelling them to Islam by the sword.
2. The permissibility of concluding a pact with them and taking jizya from
them.
3. The permissibility of enslaving their men.
4. The permissibility of ransom for their captives and bestowal of magnanimity
on them by choice.
5. The impermissibility of killing the one who accepts Islam among them after
gaining power over them.
6. Considering the two shahadas or the equivalent as their entry into Islam.
7. Takfir of the one who refrains from takfir of one of them absolutely.
And other inferences that the one who pronounces their kufr to be original
must say, or he must condemn them and fabricate a new pronouncement, and many
of the Ahl al-'Ilm condemned this type of fabrication.
Sheikh Ibn Mulla Farukh (may God have mercy on him) said: "There has spread
among the virtuous of the era the prohibition on fabrication in taqlid"- (al-Qawl
al-Sadid fi Ba'adh Masa'il al-Ijtihad wa al-Taqlid"- 1/79).
Conclusion: We ask God for the good conclusion
We have not endeavoured during the course of this treatise to make clear the
doctrines of the Shi'a sects and come upon their principles, discuss them and
respond to them, but rather we have been content to make clear the ruling on
those sects in a summary that is not weak, with our concern in it for
following and emulation, not innovation and beginning anew.
Let us thus conclude this subject of discussion among some of the youth, and
let us and them stand on making the issue a matter of principle and
foundation, without being influenced by the agitated emotions in distorting
the ruling on the matter.
So we ask God to bless this effort and make it grow, in order for it to touch
the bounds of hearts and minds.
Our last call is praise be to God the Lord of the Worlds, and God's peace and
blessings be upon the most noble of the Prophets and those sent.
Index
Introduction of the amir of the Investigations and Studies Office p. 2
Section: defining apostasy as a word and technical term p. 6
Section: Islam in the legal sense and true Islam p. 8
Section: Apostasy in the true and legal sense p. 10
Section: Kufr in the true and legal sense p. 11
Section: General Islam and particular Islam p. 13
Section: Ruling on the children of the apostates p. 15
Section: Truth of the apostasy of the Shi'a sects p. 18
Section: Some of the pronouncements of the 'ulama on the ruling on the
Rafidites p. 20
Section: Some of the pronouncements of the 'ulama on the ruling on the
Nusayris, Ismailis and Druze p. 22
Section: Some of the words of the sheikhs of the Islamic State in ruling on
the Shi'a sects p. 24
Section: The falsehood of saying that the Shi'a sects are original kuffar p.
26
Section: Conclusion- we ask God for good conclusion p. 29
[i] It is not concealed that the Druze exist in two types: one claiming
affiliation with Islam, and they are the ones meant in this treatise, and
another not claiming affiliation with Islam in principle, such people being
original kuffar without distinction.
[ii] The meaning of "the Shi'a sects" in this book: they are the Rafidites,
Nusayris, Ismailis and Druze. As for the Zaydi Shi'a, who are followers of
Zayd bin Ali Zayn al-Abidin, they are not included in our discussion.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments