Warsaw Muslim Centre Attack Renews Islamophobia Fears: 'Moral Panic' And Rising Islamophobia
30 December 2017
By Agnieszka Pikulicka-Wilczewska
On the night of Monday, November 27, two men in hoodies vandalised the Muslim
cultural centre in Warsaw, breaking windows with stones and pieces of
concrete.
The attack took place amid deepening Islamophobia in Poland, where Muslims
comprise a mere 0.1 percent of the population.
CCTV footage confirmed the incident, but in the darkness of night, the
attackers' faces are unrecognisable.
"I hope that the perpetrators will be caught soon", said Mariusz Blaszczak,
minister of interior.
So far, the men have not been named.
"This was not the first attack against our centre," said Anna Lukjanowicz, a
Polish convert to Islam who works at the institute, citing three previous
attacks.
In October this year, a masked man threw a bottle against the front door,
leaving visible marks.
"Recent events are part of a politically fuelled, unpleasant atmosphere of
xenophobia and racism in Poland," she told Al Jazeera. "Because of the verbal
and physical attacks against not only Muslims, but also people who 'look like
Muslims' - that is people with a darker skin, and the attack against the
Muslim Culture Centre, Muslims living in Poland are losing the sense of
security."
Completed in 2015, the centre's architecture blends Middle Eastern tradition
and European trends.
It hosts conference halls, a library and the largest prayer room in Poland,
with space for 600 people.
At the beginning of 2017, the centre's employees wrote to Polish officials,
including the president, the prime minister, both chambers of parliament and
all parliamentary parties, expressing their concern with the "biased media
coverage of Islam and its people" as well as the "consolidation of anti-Muslim
attitudes" in the political debate.
According to the authors, these could lead to the increase in xenophobia and
violence against Muslims.
In, 2016, police figures revealed the second highest number of hate crime
incidents after 2015, with 765 reported cases of violence. In 2014, police
recorded 262 incidents.
In 2016, local prosecutor offices investigated 1,631 hate crimes fuelled by
racism, anti-Semitism or xenophobia.
Since 2015, the number of attacks against Muslims rose from 192 to 362,
followed by attacks against Jews and Roma people.
'No explicit condemnation' from officials
In May 2016, Prime Minister Beata Szydlo abolished an anti-discrimination
council that was tasked with preventing xenophobia and intolerance.
The Muslim cultural centre's letters generated little response from the
authorities. In the only reply, in spite of evidence to the contrary, the
office of the Senate said physical attacks against the centre were unlikely.
"Facts from the Polish tradition and history show that Christian Orthodox
people, Protestants, Jews, Tatars, Ukrainians and Belarusians lived in peace
with Poles in our country, making a great contribution to its development,"
the response read.
"Apart from reporting on worrying events, which take place in some countries
of Western Europe, we have not noticed any references towards the Muslim
community, which has been living in Poland for years, that would be worth
condemning".
However, according to Anna Tatar from the anti-racist Never Again Association,
which has been monitoring hate crime incidents in Poland since the 1990s, the
political narrative in response to the refugee crisis has contributed to the
increase in anti-Muslim sentiment in Poland.
"The main reason for this change is the way the Polish debate about the
humanitarian crisis and the possible acceptance of refugees was conducted.
This is a problem which does not concern Poland at all because there are
almost no refugees here, but the hysterical way in which the issue was
discussed, used and manipulated for political ends has contributed to the
increase in violence," Tatar said.
"There are a number of examples of statements made by representatives of the
authorities, which show that they do not want to see the problem or that they
neglect it. For example, at the recent 'Independence March', a number of
openly racist banners were present. Yet, there was virtually no explicit
condemnation of the events," she said, an opinion shared by the wider Muslim
community.
Some 60,000 people joined the "Independence March" attended by some
nationalists and fascists in Warsaw on November 11 - more people than the
Polish Muslim population of around 35,000 - where chants included: "The whole
Poland sings with us: f*** off with the refugees."
"Public media and nationalist internet sites discriminate against Islam and
Muslims and manipulate the public opinion, trying to convince Poles that Islam
is a religion of violence, terror, that it is primitive," said Imam Youssef
Hadid, Chairman of the Supreme Council of the Muslim League in Poland.
"There are debates and lectures which spread hatred towards Muslims, people
who are invited to speak at them have xenophobic and Islamophobic views, have
no knowledge of Islam, and those who specialise in it are not invited."
'Moral panic' and rising Islamophobia
A study by the Center for Research on Prejudice published in September 2015,
found that although 80 percent of Poles do not know any Muslims, two-thirds
declare that they would feel uncomfortable in their presence.
More than half of respondents stated that Muslims threaten Poland's economic
well-being and Polish values, and a similar number agreed with Islamophobic
statements. Younger respondents demonstrated a higher level of fear.
"What we are currently observing is a moral panic. Polish society is easy to
manipulate. Public opinion polls show that we are the first in the EU when it
comes to viewing social media as a reliable source of information about the
world. Over half of Poles trust social media," said Adam Balcer, a
Warsaw-based researcher for the European Council on Foreign Relations. "The
Polish internet is very right wing and nationalistic, and as a result, Polish
youth has a negative attitude towards Muslims."
Since the country has one of the most ethnically and religiously homogenous
societies in Europe with a small Muslim minority, the right wing plays on
irrational fears.
"The authorities, which are openly Islamophobic, set the example. This falls
on a fertile ground of fears and phobias, which reflect some deeply rooted
stereotypes," said Balcer.
He compared the current atmosphere to the interwar period and the existing
attitudes towards Muslims to the earlier situation of Jews.
"A Jew used to be portrayed as oriental, the other, an eastern man, incapable
of assimilating and integrating, who could destroy the nation," he explained.
"Those cliches only had to be revived. You can see them in the current fears
of the Law and Justice's electorate which include the alliance of [George]
Soros and the Germans to destroy Poland's ethnic cohesion by bringing in
refugees".
Following the attack at the Muslim cultural centre, some Poles sent messages
condemning the incident and expressing solidarity. Others arrived at the scene
and brought candles.
On November 29, a group of activists organised a protest in Warsaw under the
slogan "No to Islamophobia".
Representatives of the Jewish community have also expressed their regret
concerning the attack, acknowledging the rise in negative attitudes towards
minorities in Poland.
"Poles are a hospitable nation, they are tolerant and respectful of people of
other faiths, but unfortunately politics pushes them to spread nationalism and
hate towards Muslims," Imam Hadid said.